← The Public RecordRecord of October 28, 2026 · pressed nightly · 64 meetings · 191.3 hours · no accounts · no trackingREAD · the record
MunicipalityBoston 44Brookline 20The whole recordthe whole record
Boston · City Council Committee

Ways and Means on September 28, 2026

City Council Committee · Boston · 2026-09-28

words this meeting uses collective bargaining · fiscal year (FY) · docket · appropriation · City Council · Open Meeting Law — the glossary says what they mean

tap to load the tape · nothing plays until you do
the shape of the tape — click anywhere to jump● a decision, sized by weight · | a question · ▮ tension · $ money named · the eight lanes: where each lens’s words fell
financialfinancial — 97 words, where they fell along the tapesafetysafety — 69 words, where they fell along the tapecommunitycommunity — 10 words, where they fell along the tapeenvironmentallegallegal — 5 words, where they fell along the tapeequityequity — 1 word, where they fell along the tapeinfrastructureinfrastructure — 3 words, where they fell along the tapeprocessprocess — 42 words, where they fell along the tape12:11 · equity: “PHYSICALLY ACCESSIBLE TO THE”12:14 · process: “CONDUCTING THIS HEARING”12:16 · process: “THIS HEARING IS BEING RECORDED”12:42 · process: “AT THE END OF THIS HEARING.”13:06 · process: “UH OKAY SO TODAY'S HEARING IS”13:09 · process: “ON PSYCH UH 1234 DOCKETS.”13:15 · process: “UM UH SO DOCKET NUMBER 1671 IS”13:21 · financial: “THE F Y 27 APPROPRIATION YOU'RE”13:39 · safety: “POLICE DEPARTMENT FOR THE UH”13:48 · safety: “BOSTON POLICE DETECTIVES”13:55 · safety: “FOR THE BOSTON POLICE”14:04 · financial: “COVER THE FISCAL YEAR 27 COST”14:12 · safety: “THE BOSTON POLICE DETECTIVES”14:40 · safety: “UPDATE TO HAZARDOUS DUTY PAY”14:48 · financial: “THE FISCAL YEAR 27 UH BUDGET”14:55 · financial: “SEPARATE APPROPRIATION TO FUND”15:23 · safety: “FOR THE BOSTON POLICE”15:49 · financial: “FISCAL YEAR 27 COST ITEMS”16:30 · financial: “APPROPRIATION TO FUND PROJECTED”24:08 · legal: “LEGAL DOCTRINE BUT I BELIEVE”26:26 · infrastructure: “STREET.”28:21 · infrastructure: “STREET AND THE COMMAND STAFF I”28:40 · community: “FAMILIES KNOWING KNOWING THAT”30:39 · community: “OF TIME WITH THEIR FAMILY THEN”37:06 · legal: “COUNSELOR ON THE ON THE UH ON”39:00 · legal: “I'M NOT SURE, COUNSELOR.”44:39 · legal: “ON THE SUMMARIES, COUNSELOR.”47:12 · legal: “THREE COUNSELORS HERE IF THEY”54:10 · community: “FAMILIES AND THE UNION AND TO”55:23 · community: “WOMEN AND THEIR FAMILIES AND”55:35 · community: “LONGTIME BOSTON RESIDENT”55:42 · community: “THEIR FAMILIES WITH THE”57:47 · infrastructure: “THE STREETS UM BOBBY BUT OUR”$1,951,894 +3$1,951,894 — said 2 times, first at 13:32$1,951,894 — said 1 time, first at 15:07$1,366,093 — said 2 times, first at 15:20$1,396,093 — said 1 time, first at 16:40$100,000 +2$100,000 — said 1 time, first at 53:51$60,000 — said 1 time, first at 53:54$3 — said 1 time, first at 58:06$120,000$120,000 — said 1 time, first at 1:01:2017:42 · a question: “YOU GOT YOUR HAND UP?”23:59 · a question: “AS IT'S IDENTICAL?”24:01 · a question: “IDENTICAL AMOUNTS?”24:49 · a question: “BUDGET DIRECTOR WILLIAMSON?”24:59 · a question: “OKAY, DIRECTOR?”27:43 · a question: “HAVE IN THE CITY?”27:56 · a question: “WHAT'S THE WHAT'S THE MOST UP?”28:27 · a question: “WE VOTE ON THIS?”28:50 · a question: “CRITICAL TIME OFF?”28:58 · a question: “FOR THE POLICE DEPARTMENT?”29:33 · a question: “HAS BEEN CUT THOUGH, HASN'T IT?”29:35 · a question: “OF THE POLICE?”30:04 · a question: “EFFECTIVE ON THEIR JOB?”31:01 · a question: “YOU GOT ANOTHER MINUTE LEFT?”32:39 · a question: “JUST EXPLAIN?”38:13 · a question: “PATROL OFFICERS?”39:15 · a question: “VOTE ON THIS WEDNESDAY?”39:51 · a question: “ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS?”42:59 · a question: “UP UNTIL WHEN?”43:25 · a question: “THAT WILL END?”44:26 · a question: “ANY CHANGES FOR HEALTH CARE?”44:52 · a question: “VOTING LIKE WHAT?”46:38 · a question: “COUNCILOR FITZGERALD?”47:08 · a question: “YOU GOT A COUPLE MINUTES?”14:42 · decision: “THE CONTRACT ALSO CONTAINS AN UPDATE TO HAZARDOUS DUTY PAY AND AMENDED LANGUAGE AROUND SICK TIME BUYBACK AT RETIREMENT…”16:16 · decision: “THE CONTRACT ALSO CONTAINS AN UPDATE TO HAZARDOUS DUTY PAY AND AMENDED LANGUAGE AROUND PAY DETAILS AND SUMMER VACATION…”16:50 · decision: “UH, FOR MY COLLEAGUES YOU MAY RECALL WE PASSED SIMILAR DOCKETS IN MAY OF THIS YEAR UH FOR FISCAL YEAR 2026.”18:13 · decision: “THEY ARE NOT BECAUSE WE WE THIS IS I BELIEVE AND MR WILLIAMSON, THE BUDGET DIRECTOR WILLIAMSON IS GOING TO EXPLAIN WE…”18:53 · decision: “I DON'T I DON'T MISS ANY OF THESE HEARINGS BUT I, UM I WANT TO DO MY DUE DILIGENCE BEFORE I DO VOTE.”23:00 · decision: “UH, SO IN UH IN MAY, UH, SOME COUNCIL PASSED AND APPROVED A SUPPLEMENTAL BUDGET FOR THAT ONE YEAR CONTRACT THAT…”24:04 · decision: “UM, AS THE ONES THAT WERE APPROVED IN MAY.”24:30 · decision: “EXPIRED BUT THEY STILL HAVE THOSE WAGE PROVISIONS THAT WERE APPROVED AND THE BUDGET NEEDS TO BE ADJUSTED TO ACCOMMODATE…”28:27 · decision: “CAN WE GET THAT NUMBER BEFORE WE VOTE ON THIS?”32:40 · decision: “SO WE VOTED IN MAY TO APPROVE 2% INCREASES THAT WERE, UH, YOU KNOW, TAKEN MONEY OUT OF THE, UH, THE RESERVE.”33:10 · decision: “COUNCIL I THINK WHAT YOU SAID UH, BEFORE IS EVEN THOUGH THE CONTRACTS EXPIRE, THE THE EXISTING TERMS OF THE CONTRACT…”35:53 · decision: “COME UP BECAUSE I HAVE SOME SPECIFIC QUESTIONS THAT MAY BE NEW INFORMATION FROM THE LAST TIME AND IF WE'RE GOING TO…”0:0030:001:00:0023:00
the same, as a table
timekindthe moment
14:42decisionTHE CONTRACT ALSO CONTAINS AN UPDATE TO HAZARDOUS DUTY PAY AND AMENDED LANGUAGE AROUND SICK TIME BUYBACK AT RETIREMENT…
16:16decisionTHE CONTRACT ALSO CONTAINS AN UPDATE TO HAZARDOUS DUTY PAY AND AMENDED LANGUAGE AROUND PAY DETAILS AND SUMMER VACATION…
16:50decisionUH, FOR MY COLLEAGUES YOU MAY RECALL WE PASSED SIMILAR DOCKETS IN MAY OF THIS YEAR UH FOR FISCAL YEAR 2026.
18:13decisionTHEY ARE NOT BECAUSE WE WE THIS IS I BELIEVE AND MR WILLIAMSON, THE BUDGET DIRECTOR WILLIAMSON IS GOING TO EXPLAIN WE…
18:53decisionI DON'T I DON'T MISS ANY OF THESE HEARINGS BUT I, UM I WANT TO DO MY DUE DILIGENCE BEFORE I DO VOTE.
23:00decisionUH, SO IN UH IN MAY, UH, SOME COUNCIL PASSED AND APPROVED A SUPPLEMENTAL BUDGET FOR THAT ONE YEAR CONTRACT THAT…
24:04decisionUM, AS THE ONES THAT WERE APPROVED IN MAY.
24:30decisionEXPIRED BUT THEY STILL HAVE THOSE WAGE PROVISIONS THAT WERE APPROVED AND THE BUDGET NEEDS TO BE ADJUSTED TO ACCOMMODATE…
28:27decisionCAN WE GET THAT NUMBER BEFORE WE VOTE ON THIS?
32:40decisionSO WE VOTED IN MAY TO APPROVE 2% INCREASES THAT WERE, UH, YOU KNOW, TAKEN MONEY OUT OF THE, UH, THE RESERVE.
33:10decisionCOUNCIL I THINK WHAT YOU SAID UH, BEFORE IS EVEN THOUGH THE CONTRACTS EXPIRE, THE THE EXISTING TERMS OF THE CONTRACT…
35:53decisionCOME UP BECAUSE I HAVE SOME SPECIFIC QUESTIONS THAT MAY BE NEW INFORMATION FROM THE LAST TIME AND IF WE'RE GOING TO…
13:32money$1,951,894 — said 2 times
15:07money$1,951,894 — said 1 time
15:20money$1,366,093 — said 2 times
16:40money$1,396,093 — said 1 time
53:51money$100,000 — said 1 time
53:54money$60,000 — said 1 time
58:06money$3 — said 1 time
1:01:20money$120,000 — said 1 time

↓ this picture, as .svg

the night, cut — reels the press made from this meeting’s moments
▶ the night in 1:34its 5 loudest moments, in order · plays clip to clip · the link is the share
or one kind of momentthe decisions 12 · 3:55

Cut from the analyzer’s scored moments — a measurement, not a choice made for you. Open a reel and press make this reel yours to re-cut it; tick any moment or transcript line below to cut your own.

AI summary — supplements the official record

During the September 20, 2026 hearing [11:45], the Boston City Council Committee on Ways and Means [11:42] discussed Docket 1671 [13:15] and Docket 1673 [15:09] concerning fiscal year 2027 appropriations to fund collective bargaining wage increases for the Boston Police Detectives Benevolent Society [13:32] and the Boston Police Superior Officers Unit [15:30]. Budget Director Jim Williamson detailed how the orders move funds from reserve accounts into the department budget to cover a two percent pay increase and other established contract provisions [22:05], [23:18], [32:43]. Councilors and union representative Bob Griffin [47:02] also addressed detective staffing shortages [36:22], [41:38], [47:38], heavy case loads [48:54], and union-funded health and cancer wellness screenings [28:57], [49:50], [53:35]. No votes were taken during the meeting before Chair Weber adjourned the hearing [1:08:58].

the reading, drafted by a model — ai:gemini-3.6-flash, labeled · what it meant, who moved it, what to watch · check it against the tape

What it means: Chair Weber [11:39] convened a Boston City Council Committee on Ways and Means hearing [11:42] regarding Dockets 1671 and 1673 [13:15], [15:09]. These orders transfer funds from collective bargaining reserves [15:14], [16:26] to cover FY27 cost items [13:21], [15:24], including a 2% wage increase [14:33], [16:08] totaling $1,951,894 for the Patrolmen's Benevolent Society [13:37], [13:50] and $1,366,093 for the Superior Officers and Detectives units [15:20], [15:34], [15:58]. Budget Director Jim Williamson [22:05], [22:09] explained that the transfers shift reserve allocations into the active departmental budget [23:18], [23:25] to account for approved contract terms [23:03], [24:27].

Who moved it: Chair Weber opened and led the hearing [11:39], [12:14], joined by Councilors Flynn [17:11], Murphy [34:48], and Fitzgerald [40:43]. City Budget Director Jim Williamson presented the budget details [22:05], [22:14], and Bob Griffin provided testimony on behalf of the detectives union [47:02], [47:38]. Although the transcript states that the matters were sponsored and referred to the committee [16:41], [16:44], the snippet does not explicitly list the sponsor's name [16:41].

What to watch: Chair Weber noted that the dockets could be brought up for a city council vote on Wednesday [1:06:08]. During the meeting, councilors raised questions regarding detective staffing shortages [36:22], [42:11], officers working 16-hour shifts [25:31], [28:44], and health screenings funded directly by the union [50:21], [53:51]. Councilor Flynn recalled previous budget amendment proposals for police wellness [1:06:33], [1:07:08], while Chair Weber recommended building consensus among councilors for future budget actions [1:07:56], [1:08:35]. The transcript does not show a vote being taken before the meeting adjourned [1:08:55].

the moments — the analyzer’s scored read of this meeting; click one to jump the tape

Scored, not chosen for you — the salience bar is a measurement, and every moment is a receipt into the transcript below. With JavaScript on, tick moments to compose a reel — and tick moments on other meetings too; a reel can span the record.

→ the publish kit for this meeting — the clips worth cutting and draft copy, for a producer.

how the meeting framed it — eight civic lenses, counted from its own words
financial97· steady
safety69↓ fading
process42· steady
community10↑ rising
legal5↑ rising
infrastructure3· steady
equity1· steady

Counted, not modeled — each lens is a word list; drift compares the first half to the second.

the questions asked — typed by what they ask about
the meeting in words — what was said most; press a word to find every line that says it
policepolice — 57 mentionsofficersofficers — 50 mentionscitycity — 39 mentionsdetectivesdetectives — 38 mentionsbudgetbudget — 35 mentionscontractcontract — 34 mentionshealthhealth — 30 mentionssuresure — 28 mentionsbostonboston — 27 mentionsunionunion — 27 mentionswellnesswellness — 21 mentionshearinghearing — 19 mentionsbelievebelieve — 19 mentionsworkwork — 19 mentionscouncilcouncil — 18 mentionsnumbernumber — 17 mentionsdetectivedetective — 17 mentionsdepartmentdepartment — 16 mentionswilliamsonwilliamson — 16 mentionsbargainingbargaining — 14 mentionscolleaguescolleagues — 14 mentionsjimjim — 14 mentionsdirectordirector — 14 mentionsbackback — 14 mentionslastlast — 14 mentionsconversationconversation — 14 mentionssixsix — 13 mentionscollectivecollective — 13 mentionsfiscalfiscal — 13 mentionsflynnflynn — 13 mentionsmoneymoney — 13 mentionsfirstfirst — 13 mentionsbenevolentbenevolent — 12 mentionspaypay — 12 mentionswagewage — 11 mentionshearhear — 11 mentionspatrolpatrol — 11 mentionsorderorder — 10 mentionssuperiorsuperior — 10 mentionsguessguess — 10 mentionsissuesissues — 10 mentionsyearsyears — 10 mentionsputput — 10 mentionsincreasesincreases — 9 mentionsmaybemaybe — 9 mentionsimportantimportant — 9 mentionsanswersanswers — 9 mentionsgettinggetting — 9 mentionssupportsupport — 9 mentionsappropriationappropriation — 8 mentionssocietysociety — 8 mentionsmurphymurphy — 8 mentionsaskask — 8 mentionsgivegive — 8 mentionsmuchmuch — 8 mentionsexpiredexpired — 8 mentionsaddressaddress — 8 mentionsworkingworking — 8 mentionsansweranswer — 8 mentionsmeanmean — 8 mentions
the same, as a table
wordmentions
police57
officers50
city39
detectives38
budget35
contract34
health30
sure28
boston27
union27
wellness21
hearing19
believe19
work19
council18
number17
detective17
department16
williamson16
bargaining14
colleagues14
jim14
director14
back14
last14
conversation14
six13
collective13
fiscal13
flynn13
money13
first13
benevolent12
pay12
wage11
hear11
patrol11
order10
superior10
guess10
issues10
years10
put10
increases9
maybe9
important9
answers9
getting9
support9
appropriation8
society8
murphy8
ask8
give8
much8
expired8
address8
working8
answer8
mean8

↓ this picture, as .svg

“police” came up 57 times. Sized by how often; civic stopwords out. With JavaScript off, a word opens the tape at its first mention.

transcript — select any line to Cite it, click a time to jump; + on a line cuts it into your reel transcript .txtkit .json

11:39 WEBER I'M THE DISTRICT SIX CITY

11:41 COUNCILOR AND THE CHAIR OF THE

11:42 BOSTON CITY COUNCIL ON WAYS AND

11:44 MEANS.

11:45 TODAY'S UH SEPTEMBER 20TH, 2026

11:48 AND THE EXACT TIME IS 10:04

11:50 A.M..

11:51 UH IN ACCORDANCE WITH CHAPTER

11:53 TWO OF THE ACTS OF 2025

11:55 MODIFYING CERTAIN REQUIREMENTS

11:57 OF THE OPEN MEETING LAW AND UH,

12:00 RELIVING OR RELIEVING UH,

12:02 SORRY PUBLIC BODIES OF CERTAIN

12:04 REQUIREMENTS INCLUDING THE

12:05 REQUIREMENT THAT PUBLIC BODIES

12:07 CONDUCT UH, MEETINGS IN A

12:09 PUBLIC PLACE THAT'S OPEN AND

12:11 PHYSICALLY ACCESSIBLE TO THE

12:12 PUBLIC.

12:13 THE CITY COUNCIL WILL BE

12:14 CONDUCTING THIS HEARING

12:15 VIRTUALLY VIA ZOOM.

12:16 THIS HEARING IS BEING RECORDED

12:18 .

12:18 IT'S ALSO BEING LIVE STREAMED

12:20 AT BOSTON.GOV/CITY COUNCIL TV

12:23 AND BROADCAST ON XFINITY

12:24 CHANNEL EIGHT, RCN CHANNEL 82,

12:27 IN FAVOR OF CHANNEL 964.

12:29 UH WRITTEN COMMENTS MAY BE SENT

12:31 TO THE COMMITTEE EMAIL AT UH

12:34 CCW UM@BOSTON.GOV IT WILL BE

12:37 MADE A PART OF THE RECORD AND

12:38 AVAILABLE TO ALL COUNCILORS.

12:40 PUBLIC TESTIMONY WILL BE TAKEN

12:42 AT THE END OF THIS HEARING.

12:43 INDIVIDUALS WILL BE CALLED ON

12:45 IN THE ORDER IN WHICH THEY'VE

12:46 SIGNED UP AND WILL HAVE TWO

12:47 MINUTES TO TESTIFY IF YOU WISH

12:49 TO SIGN UP FOR PUBLIC TESTIMONY

12:50 YOU'VE NOT DONE SO ALREADY,

12:52 PLEASE EMAIL OUR CENTRAL STAFF

12:54 LIAISON KARISHMA ON.

12:55 YEAH.

12:57 KKR.

13:02 MQ HAND@BOSTON.GOV FOR THE ZOOM

13:03 LINK AND YOUR NAME WILL BE

13:04 ADDED TO THE LIST.

13:06 UH OKAY SO TODAY'S HEARING IS

13:09 ON PSYCH UH 1234 DOCKETS.

13:13 UH I'M GOING TO READ THEM OUT

13:15 UM UH SO DOCKET NUMBER 1671 IS

13:19 A MESSAGE IN ORDER TO REDUCE

13:21 THE F Y 27 APPROPRIATION YOU'RE

13:24 JUST GOING TO ON SECOND AND FY

13:27 27 APPROPRIATION FOR THE

13:30 RESERVE, UH, FOR COLLECTIVE

13:32 BARGAINING BY $1,951,894 TO

13:37 PROVIDE FUNDING FOR THE BOSTON

13:39 POLICE DEPARTMENT FOR THE UH

13:41 FISCAL YEAR 27 INCREASES

13:44 CONTAINED WITHIN THE COLLECTIVE

13:45 BARGAINING AGREEMENTS BETWEEN

13:46 THE CITY OF BOSTON AND THE

13:48 BOSTON POLICE DETECTIVES

13:50 BENEVOLENT SOCIETY DOCKET

13:52 NUMBER 1672 MESSAGE IN ORDER

13:55 FOR THE BOSTON POLICE

13:56 DEPARTMENT FOR FISCAL YEAR 27,

13:58 IN THE AMOUNT OF $1,951,894 TO

14:04 COVER THE FISCAL YEAR 27 COST

14:06 ITEMS CONTAINED WITHIN THE

14:08 COLLECTIVE BARGAINING AGREEMENT

14:10 BETWEEN THE CITY OF BOSTON AND

14:12 THE BOSTON POLICE DETECTIVES

14:14 BENEVOLENT SOCIETY.

14:15 THE TERMS OF THE CONTRACT ARE

14:18 IT SAYS HERE JULY 1ST 2025 TO

14:23 JUNE 30TH 2026.

14:25 UH MAYBE UH WE HAVE TO CHANGE

14:27 THAT AMEND THAT.

14:28 THE MAJOR PROVISIONS OF THE

14:30 CONTRACT INCLUDE A BASE WAGE

14:33 INCREASE OF 2% IN JULY 2025

14:36 AGAIN, UH, I'M NOT SURE ABOUT

14:38 THE YEAR.

14:38 THE CONTRACT ALSO CONTAINS AN

14:40 UPDATE TO HAZARDOUS DUTY PAY

14:42 AND AMENDED LANGUAGE AROUND

14:43 SICK TIME BUYBACK AT RETIREMENT

14:46 AS ORIGINALLY PRESENTED TO YOU

14:48 THE FISCAL YEAR 27 UH BUDGET

14:51 REQUEST INCLUDED A RESERVE FOR

14:53 COLLECTIVE BARGAINING, A

14:55 SEPARATE APPROPRIATION TO FUND

14:57 PROJECTED COLLECTIVE BARGAINING

14:59 INCREASES.

14:59 A SEPARATE ORDER HAS BEEN FILED

15:01 TO REDUCE THE APPROPRIATION BY

15:07 $1,951,894.

15:07 OKAY, I THINK I GET DOCKET

15:09 NUMBER 1673 MESSAGE IN ORDER TO

15:12 REDUCE THE FISCAL YEAR 27

15:14 APPROPRIATION FOR THE RESERVE

15:15 FOR COLLECTIVE BARGAINING BY

15:20 $1,366,093 TO PROVIDE FUNDING

15:23 FOR THE BOSTON POLICE

15:24 DEPARTMENT FOR THE FISCAL YEAR

15:26 27 INCREASES CONTAINED WITHIN

15:28 THE COLLECTIVE BARGAINING

15:29 AGREEMENTS BETWEEN THE CITY

15:30 OF BOSTON AND THE BOSTON POLICE

15:32 UH DETECTIVE BENEVOLENT SOCIETY

15:34 SUPERIOR OFFICERS UNIT AND UH

15:37 FINALLY, UH DOCKET NUMBER 1674

15:39 MESSAGE IN ORDER FOR THE BOSTON

15:41 POLICE DEPARTMENT FOR FISCAL

15:42 YEAR 27, IN THE AMOUNT

15:48 OF $1,366,093 TO COVER THE

15:49 FISCAL YEAR 27 COST ITEMS

15:51 CONTAINED WITHIN THE COLLECTIVE

15:53 BARGAINING AGREEMENT BETWEEN

15:54 THE CITY OF BOSTON AND THE

15:55 BOSTON POLICE DETECTIVES

15:56 BENEVOLENT SOCIETY SUPERIOR

15:58 OFFICERS UNIT.

15:59 THE TERMS OF THE CONTRACT ARE

16:01 JULY 1ST, 2025 THROUGH JUNE

16:03 30TH OF 2026.

16:05 THE MAJOR PROVISIONS OF THE

16:06 CONTRACT INCLUDE A BASE WAGE

16:08 INCREASE OF 2% IN JULY 2025.

16:12 THE CONTRACT ALSO CONTAINS AN

16:14 UPDATE TO HAZARDOUS DUTY PAY

16:16 AND AMENDED LANGUAGE AROUND PAY

16:18 DETAILS AND SUMMER VACATION

16:20 SCHEDULES AS ORIGINALLY

16:22 PRESENTED TO YOU, THE FISCAL

16:23 YEAR 27 BUDGET REQUEST INCLUDED

16:26 A RESERVE FOR COLLECTIVE

16:28 BARGAINING UH, A SEPARATE

16:30 APPROPRIATION TO FUND PROJECTED

16:31 BARGAINING COLLECTIVE

16:32 BARGAINING INCREASES A SEPARATE

16:34 ORDER HAS BEEN FILED TO REDUCE

16:35 THAT APPROPRIATION BY

16:40 $1,396,093.

16:41 THESE MATTERS WERE SPONSORED BY

16:43 MICHELLE WU AND WERE REFERRED

16:44 TO THE COMMITTEE.

16:45 ON SEPTEMBER 16TH, 2026.

16:48 UH, FOR MY COLLEAGUES YOU MAY

16:50 RECALL WE PASSED SIMILAR

16:51 DOCKETS IN MAY OF THIS YEAR UH

16:54 FOR FISCAL YEAR 2026.

16:57 THESE DOCKETS I BELIEVE WOULD

16:58 JUST EXTEND THOSE UH

17:01 APPROPRIATIONS FOR FISCAL YEAR

17:03 2027.

17:04 BUT WE'RE GOING TO HEAR FROM

17:05 JIM WILLIAMSON.

17:06 UH, TODAY I'M UH JOINED BY MY

17:09 COLLEAGUES IN ORDER OF ARRIVAL

17:11 COUNCILOR FLYNN AND THEN

17:12 COUNCILOR MURPHY.

17:14 UH, I UH I'M JUST GOING TO GO

17:16 TO THE UH, PANELISTS AND THEN

17:18 WE'LL GO FOR QUESTIONS.

17:20 UH, WE'VE BEEN JOINED TODAY BY

17:22 UH, BUDGET DIRECTOR UH, JIM

17:24 WILLIAMSON.

17:25 UM, SO UH, WITH THAT I UH I

17:29 GUESS UM, IF SHE HAD JIM IS

17:33 HERE WHICH I SEE UH, DO YOU

17:35 WANT TO JUST EXPLAIN WHAT'S

17:36 GOING ON AND THEN, UH, UM, YOU

17:39 KNOW, IF MY MY COLLEAGUES HAVE

17:41 ANY QUESTIONS I SEE

17:42 COUNCILOR FLYNN.

17:42 YOU GOT YOUR HAND UP?

17:43 YEAH.

17:44 ONE QUICK QUESTION,

17:45 MR CHAIR.

17:45 WITH THE, UM.

17:47 REPRESENTATIVES FROM THE

17:48 RESPECTIVE.

17:48 RESPECTIVE UNIONS, UM.

17:51 LEADERSHIP PLANNING TO ATTEND.

17:53 THEY ARE NOT BECAUSE WE WE THIS

17:57 IS I BELIEVE AND MR WILLIAMSON,

17:59 THE BUDGET DIRECTOR WILLIAMSON

18:00 IS GOING TO EXPLAIN WE HAD A

18:02 HEARING IN MAY ON THE CONTRACT

18:04 ON A NEW CONTRACT AND I I'M I'M

18:07 HAPPY TO GO OVER UH THE

18:10 PROVISIONS THE NEW PROVISIONS

18:11 IN THE CONTRACT THAT WE

18:12 COVERED IN MAY AND THAT WE

18:13 VOTED ON IN MAY.

18:14 UH, SO THIS IS REALLY I BELIEVE

18:17 WE'RE JUST GOING INTO THE NEXT

18:19 FISCAL YEAR TO COVER THE WAGE

18:20 INCREASES THAT WERE COVERED BY

18:21 THAT CONTRACT.

18:23 SO I THINK WE'RE WE'RE ONLY

18:24 EXPECTING BUDGET DIRECTOR

18:25 WILLIAMSON TODAY.

18:26 I GUESS IF THERE'S OTHER

18:27 QUESTIONS I CAN RELAY THEM.

18:29 UH, YOU CAN REVIEW THEM THROUGH

18:31 THE CHAIR AND UH, WE CAN GET

18:33 OTHER THINGS ANSWERED.

18:34 BUT I THINK JUST TO EXPLAIN

18:36 WHAT IS HAPPENING, WE HAD, UH,

18:38 JIM WILLIAMSON HERE AND UH, FOR

18:41 QUESTIONS ABOUT THE CONTRACT

18:42 ITSELF.

18:43 I THINK WE COVERED ALL THAT

18:44 BACK IN MAY.

18:45 YEAH.

18:46 I REMEMBER BEING ON THAT.

18:47 YEAH, RIGHT.

18:48 I DON'T I DON'T MISS ANY

18:49 OF THESE HEARINGS BUT I, UM I

18:52 WANT TO DO MY DUE DILIGENCE

18:53 BEFORE I DO VOTE.

18:55 OKAY.

18:56 YEAH.

18:56 THANK YOU.

18:56 YEAH.

18:57 NO, IT'S A IT'S A BIT UNUSUAL.

18:59 UH, AND SO I'VE GONE OVER THE

19:00 COMMITTEE REPORT, UM, LET'S SEE

19:03 WHICH I'VE GOT RIGHT HERE JUST

19:05 TO REFRESH FOLKS MEMORIES, YOU

19:07 KNOW, AS A NEW CONTRACT, UH,

19:09 REACHED UH TO SORT OF EXTEND

19:11 CERTAIN BENEFITS THAT WERE IN

19:13 THE PATROL OFFICERS CONTRACT TO

19:14 THE TO THE DETECTIVES

19:16 BENEVOLENT SOCIETY AND THE

19:18 DETECTIVES BENEVOLENT SOCIETY

19:20 SUPERIOR OFFICERS AND THEN I'LL

19:21 JUST RUN THROUGH THE BULLET

19:22 POINTS.

19:23 WELL.

19:23 LET ME JUST ASK.

19:24 WHERE THEY WERE.

19:26 THEY INVITED.

19:28 UH THEY WERE NOT INVITE WE HAD

19:30 A DISCUSSION ABOUT WHAT THIS

19:31 HEARING SHOULD BE AND BECAUSE

19:34 WE HAD HAD SO NO I DID NOT

19:36 INVITE THEM.

19:37 I DO THINK I DO THINK AN

19:40 INVITATION.

19:41 SHOULD BE.

19:41 EXTENDED WHETHER UM.

19:44 AT LEAST GIVE THEM THE

19:45 OPPORTUNITY TO.

19:48 UM BE INVITED TO BE.

19:49 INCLUDED BECAUSE.

19:50 THERE MIGHT.

19:50 BE SOME ISSUES.

19:51 THAT THEY HIGHLIGHT THAT MIGHT

19:54 HELP US DO OUR JOB BETTER.

19:56 CERTAINLY THE CITY OF BOSTON IS

19:58 GOING TO PRESENT THEIR

20:02 RECOMMENDATIONS, BUT.

20:02 I DO LIKE TO GET BOTH SIDES

20:04 OF THE STORY.

20:05 UM, I REALLY.

20:07 WISH THE.

20:09 UNION LEADERSHIP WERE INVITED

20:10 AND IF THEY DECLINED THEN THEY

20:12 DECLINED.

20:12 BUT I I DO.

20:13 THINK WE WE WE.

20:15 OWE IT TO THEM TO.

20:17 PAY BECAUSE OF THEIR

20:19 PROFESSIONALISM AND THE WORK

20:19 THEY DO.

20:20 TO AT.

20:21 LEAST INVITE THEM TO THE

20:22 MEETING.

20:22 OKAY.

20:23 SO THANK YOU VERY MUCH.

20:24 LET'S JUST WELL WE'LL LET'S

20:26 PROCEED UH, WITH BUDGET

20:27 DIRECTOR WILLIAMSON.

20:29 YEAH BUT BETTER BETTER IN

20:30 ADDITION TO THAT THAT'S AN A

20:32 THAT'S AN.

20:32 IMPORTANT THAT'S AN.

20:33 IMPORTANT MATTER AND WHAT

20:34 YOU'RE JUST GLOSSING OVER IT I.

20:36 DO I DO THINK IT'S AN ISSUE

20:37 THAT WE.

20:38 CAN AT LEAST.

20:39 ACKNOWLEDGE THAT THE.

20:41 UNIONS SHOULD BE.

20:42 PART OF THE DISCUSSION.

20:43 THAT'S WHAT I BELIEVE IN.

20:44 YEAH I HEAR YOU BUT LET'S JUST

20:45 LET'S LET'S HEAR IT,

20:47 MR DIRECTOR AND.

20:48 QUICK QUESTION JUST I AND

20:50 I'M LOOKING FORWARD TO HEARING

20:51 FROM JIM BUT IS IT BOTH I'M

20:54 READING THE INVITATION HERE.

20:56 IS IT BOTH THE BENEVOLENT

20:58 DETECTIVES AND THE SUPERIOR

21:00 OFFICES OR JUST THE BENEVOLENT

21:02 DETECTIVES?

21:03 IT'S THE UH THIS I'M SORRY.

21:06 LET ME JUST UM.

21:09 THEN IT SAYS HERE WE HAVE THAT

21:11 IT'S ALSO AND SO.

21:13 WAS THE BENEVOLENT DETECTIVES

21:14 AND THEN THE BENEVOLENT

21:16 DETECTIVE SUPERIOR OFFICER.

21:18 SO IT'S NOT ALWAYS THE OFFICERS

21:19 .

21:19 IT'S BOTH.

21:20 YES.

21:20 RIGHT.

21:21 SO BECAUSE THERE'S THREE POLICE

21:22 UNION SO THIS COVERS BOTH NOT

21:26 BPP BUT THE OTHER TWO.

21:28 CORRECT OKAY JUST CHECK.

21:30 DIDN'T WORK.

21:31 OKAY.

21:32 UM SO AGAIN UH WE CAN LET'S

21:37 CIRCLE BACK TO

21:39 COUNCILOR FLYNN'S, UH, CONCERNS

21:41 UH, BEFORE WE CLOSE OUT THE

21:43 HEARING.

21:44 UH, BUT SO I'M GOING TO PASS

21:46 THIS ON.

21:46 I SEE YOUR HAND IS UP AGAIN.

21:49 COUNCILOR MURPHY YOU JUST SAW,

21:50 RIGHT?

21:50 NO, JUST TAKING IT DOWN.

21:52 NO.

21:53 OKAY, OKAY.

21:53 I DON'T KNOW IF IT COULD HAVE

21:54 GONE BACK.

21:55 UH, OKAY.

21:56 UH, DIRECTOR WILLIAMSON, DO YOU

21:58 WANT TO EXPLAIN WHAT'S GOING ON

22:00 HERE?

22:00 VERY SURE.

22:01 SO THANK YOU.

22:02 CHAIR WEBER AND COUNCILORS, UH,

22:04 MURPHY AND FLYNN.

22:05 UH, MY NAME IS JIM WILLIAMSON.

22:08 I'M A BUDGET DIRECTOR HERE AT

22:09 THE CITY OF BOSTON.

22:09 AND I APPRECIATE THIS

22:11 OPPORTUNITY TO, UH, PROVIDE

22:12 MORE INFORMATION ABOUT THESE,

22:14 UH, SUPPLEMENTAL BUDGETS AND

22:15 THEIR IMPACT ON ON THE CITY'S

22:17 BUDGET.

22:17 UH, I'M HERE TO DISCUSS THE

22:19 FOUR APPROPRIATION WHEREAS

22:20 BEFORE YOU, UH, THE IMPACT

22:22 OF THE 427 ANNUAL OPERATING

22:24 BUDGET AND TO FORMALLY REQUEST

22:26 ,UH, FAVORABLE CONSIDERATION

22:28 OR RECOMMENDATION FOR THE NEXT

22:29 COUNCIL MEETING, UH, AS OUR

22:32 COUNCIL MEMBER SAID, IF THERE'S

22:33 ADDITIONAL SORT OF, UH, UNION

22:36 CONTRACT LANGUAGE SPECIFIC

22:38 QUESTIONS AND OR UH

22:40 DEPARTMENTAL OPERATION

22:41 QUESTIONS WERE HAPPY TO TO UH

22:43 REACH OUT AND GET THOSE

22:44 RESPONDED TO UM SO UH THIS UH I

22:49 THINK THERE WAS SOME DISCUSSION

22:50 ABOUT THE TERM OF THE CONTRACT.

22:50 THE CONTRACT ACTUALLY THIS

22:52 CONTRACT IS AN EXPIRED VERSION

22:53 OF A CONTRACT AND IT'S A SIMPLE

22:56 TRANSACTION.

22:56 UH, SO IN UH IN MAY, UH, SOME

23:00 COUNCIL PASSED AND APPROVED A

23:02 SUPPLEMENTAL BUDGET FOR THAT

23:03 ONE YEAR CONTRACT THAT EXPIRED,

23:05 UH, LAST JUNE, UM, IN ORDER TO

23:08 KEEP IT UH, CONSISTENT WITH UH

23:10 ,UH, PATROL OFFICERS, UH,

23:12 CONTRACT UM AND THEN UH, SO, UH

23:16 ,THIS THIS TRANSACTION IS

23:18 REALLY JUST TO MOVE UH, THE

23:20 BUDGETARY DOLLARS FROM THE 27

23:21 RESERVE INTO UH, THE 27 BUDGET

23:24 FOR THE POLICE DEPARTMENT.

23:25 UM, AND IT'S BECAUSE UH, IT UH

23:29 ,HAPPENED POST UH THE

23:31 RECOMMENDED BUDGET UH, IN APRIL

23:32 AND THAT'S WHY WE'RE

23:34 TRANSACTING IT AT THIS POINT.

23:36 UH, BUT THE THE CONTRACT IS IS

23:39 UH UM BEEN IMPLEMENTED UH, THE

23:42 UM THE DETECTIVES HAVE ALREADY

23:43 RECEIVED THEIR WAGES, YOU KNOW

23:45 ,WAGE CHANGES.

23:46 UH, AND ACTUALLY THE TERM

23:48 OF THE CONTRACT IS EXPIRED, SO.

23:52 OKAY.

23:53 AND THAT EXPLAINS IT JUST

23:54 BEFORE I GO TO COUNCILOR FLYNN,

23:56 THAT EXPLAINS WHY IT'S THE

23:57 SAME.

23:57 IS IT THE SAME NUMBER.

23:59 AS IT'S IDENTICAL?

24:01 IDENTICAL AMOUNTS?

24:02 UM, AS THE ONES THAT WERE

24:04 APPROVED IN MAY.

24:05 OKAY.

24:06 AND I I'M BLANKING ON THE

24:08 LEGAL DOCTRINE BUT I BELIEVE

24:09 WHEN YOU HAVE A COLLECTIVE

24:10 BARGAINING AGREEMENT.

24:11 AND.

24:11 IT.

24:12 EXPIRES YOU YOU DON'T LIKE JUST

24:14 NOT HAVE AN AGREEMENT YOU

24:16 MAINTAIN THE EXISTING AGREEMENT

24:18 GOING FORWARD RATHER THAN

24:20 HAVING EVERYONE JUST, YOU KNOW

24:22 ,BE UP IN THE AIR.

24:23 SO UH, THAT'S THAT IS THAT

24:25 THAT'S WHAT'S GOING ON HERE.

24:26 THE CONTRACTS EXPIRED.

24:27 EXPIRED BUT THEY STILL HAVE

24:28 THOSE WAGE PROVISIONS THAT WERE

24:30 APPROVED AND THE BUDGET NEEDS

24:31 TO BE ADJUSTED TO ACCOMMODATE

24:33 FOR THAT INCREASED COSTS.

24:35 OKAY.

24:36 UM OKAY.

24:37 UH I'M JUST I'M GOING TO GO TO

24:39 MY COLLEAGUES AND THEN IF I

24:40 HAVE QUESTIONS AT THE END UH, I

24:43 GUESS COUNCILOR FLYNN UH, I HAD

24:47 IT.

24:48 DO YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS FOR

24:49 BUDGET DIRECTOR WILLIAMSON?

24:50 I UNDERSTAND YOUR YOUR CONCERN

24:52 AND WE WILL WE'LL TALK ABOUT

24:53 THAT ON THE RECORD BEFORE WE

24:56 CLOSE THE HEARING.

24:57 BUT, UM, DO YOU HAVE QUESTIONS

24:59 FOR.

24:59 OKAY, DIRECTOR?

25:01 THANK YOU, MR CHAIR.

25:03 THANK YOU.

25:03 JIM.

25:04 JIM, WHAT IS THE, UM.

25:07 ANY ANY SPECIFIC LANGUAGE AS IT

25:09 RELATES TO.

25:13 THE THE ONGOING UM.

25:17 DEBATE OR CHALLENGE AS IT

25:19 RELATES TO.

25:19 THE THE NUMBER OF POLICE

25:23 OFFICERS WE HAVE IN THE CITY

25:25 AND THE FREQUENCY OF 16 HOUR

25:28 WORK WORKDAYS, UM, AND

25:31 OVERSTAFFED OFFICES UM

25:35 DANGEROUSLY UM UNDERSTAFFED.

25:38 OVERWORKED UM LIMITED NUMBER

25:40 OF POLICE OFFICERS.

25:42 DOES THE LANGUAGE ADDRESS ANY

25:44 OF THAT?

25:46 UH UH I UH I WOULD DEFER TO UH,

25:48 LABOR RELATIONS BUT I DO NOT

25:50 BELIEVE THE CONTRACT SPEAKS TO

25:51 THE SPECIFIC NUMBER OF OFFICERS

25:54 .

25:58 IT JUST ACKNOWLEDGES I THINK IN

26:00 A SUMMARY IT ACKNOWLEDGES HOW

26:01 MANY UM, OFFICERS WERE UH, WERE

26:05 IN THAT ROLE.

26:07 SO I THINK UH, FOR THE UM.

26:12 THE UH, DETECTIVES AS 278

26:15 MEMBERS UH, AND FOR THE

26:18 SUPERIOR DETECTIVES IT'S 127

26:21 MEMBERS.

26:23 SO I, I HEARD FROM.

26:25 DETECTIVES ON THE ON THE

26:26 STREET.

26:26 YEAH.

26:27 AND THEY ARE TELLING ME THEY

26:29 HAVE THEY DON'T HAVE ENOUGH

26:32 DETECTIVES.

26:33 TO DO.

26:33 THE INVESTIGATIVE WORK AND

26:36 THEY'RE SHORT STAFFED.

26:38 HOW WILL WE ADDRESS THE MAXIMUM

26:41 GANG?

26:41 YOU KNOW, I YOU KNOW, I DO

26:43 REMEMBER SORT OF UM, UH, POLICE

26:46 REPRESENTATIVES TALKING ABOUT

26:47 THAT DYNAMIC BECAUSE WHAT WHAT

26:49 WHEN YOU DON'T COME FROM THE

26:51 OUTSIDE AND BECOME A DETECTIVE,

26:53 IT'S A PROMOTIONAL OPPORTUNITY

26:54 WITHIN THE DEPARTMENT.

26:55 UH, SO I THINK THEY TRY TO, UM

26:59 ,WORK COLLABORATIVELY WITH

27:01 EACH OTHER TO MAKE SURE THAT

27:02 THEY'RE NOT DRAWING TOO MANY

27:04 FROM THE REGULAR PATROL STAFF

27:07 OR OR SUPERIOR OFFICER STAFF,

27:09 UH, THAT ARE INVOLVED AND YOU

27:11 KNOW, UH, THE DISTRICT PATROL

27:12 FORCE UH, YOU KNOW, IN UH SO I

27:17 THINK THIS UH IS AN ONGOING

27:18 CONVERSATION AND YOU KNOW,

27:20 WORKING RELATIONSHIP ON THAT

27:21 PART.

27:22 YEAH.

27:23 BUT I PREFER I PREFER THE

27:24 POLICE ACTUALLY ABOUT THE.

27:26 WELL, THAT'S THAT'S WHY THAT'S

27:28 WHY THAT'S WHY I AND THAT'S WHY

27:30 I BELIEVE IT'S IMPORTANT TO

27:31 HAVE REPRESENTATIVES FROM THE

27:33 POLICE HERE.

27:35 UM, SO SO SO WE SO THEY CAN

27:37 ANSWER THOSE QUESTIONS.

27:39 UM.

27:41 JIM, HOW.

27:42 MANY POLICE OFFICERS DO WE

27:43 HAVE IN THE CITY?

27:44 YOU KNOW, IT'S IT'S IT'S OVER,

27:47 UH, 2000 BUT I'D HAVE TO GET

27:49 YOU A SPECIFIC NUMBER.

27:50 UH, WE DO GET REPORTS FROM THE

27:52 POLICE DEPARTMENT.

27:53 UH, I LOOKED AT IT RECENTLY.

27:55 BUT WHAT'S.

27:56 WHAT'S THE WHAT'S THE MOST UP?

27:57 WHAT'S THE MOST UPDATED NUMBER

27:58 ?

27:59 UH, I'D HAVE TO GET THROUGH

28:01 THAT.

28:01 YOU ALSO HAVE.

28:03 UM.

28:04 I THINK WE USE WE WE, UM,

28:07 IDENTIFY MOST SWORN.

28:08 SO IT INCLUDES THE FOUR POLICE

28:10 UNIONS.

28:11 YEAH.

28:11 RIGHT.

28:11 YEAH, YEAH.

28:12 SWORN OFFICERS WHICH WOULD BE.

28:15 UM THE THE THE.

28:16 THE POLICE OFFICERS THAT ARE

28:18 THAT ARE BASICALLY ON THE

28:21 STREET AND THE COMMAND STAFF I

28:23 GUESS.

28:23 BUT UM, CAN.

28:25 CAN WE GET THAT NUMBER BEFORE

28:27 WE VOTE ON THIS?

28:28 SURE, ABSOLUTELY.

28:30 UM.

28:34 WHAT ARE WE DOING JIM.

28:36 ON HEALTH AND WELLNESS

28:38 OF POLICE OFFICERS AND THEIR

28:40 FAMILIES KNOWING KNOWING THAT

28:42 POLICE OFFICERS UH,

28:44 CONSISTENTLY WORKING 16 HOURS A

28:46 DAY HOW HOW ARE WE SUPPORTING

28:49 THEM.

28:49 WITH THE.

28:50 CRITICAL TIME OFF?

28:51 BUT HOW ARE WE SUPPORTING THEM.

28:53 WITH WORK.

28:54 LIFE BALANCE EVEN AS WE CUT THE

28:57 HEALTH AND WELLNESS PROGRAMS

28:58 FOR THE POLICE DEPARTMENT?

29:02 WELL, I YOU KNOW, I THINK THERE

29:04 IS UH UM THE BUDGET DOES

29:06 INCLUDE RESOURCES FOR HEALTH

29:07 AND WELLNESS PROGRAMS AT THE

29:09 POLICE DEPARTMENT.

29:09 UH, THERE'S BEEN UH, INVEST UH

29:12 INVESTMENTS IN THE LAST YEARS

29:14 UH, IN THEIR OCCUPATIONAL

29:16 HEALTH, YOU KNOW, RESOURCES TO

29:18 SORT OF, UH, HELP FACILITATE

29:20 OFFICERS WHO ARE UH, UH,

29:22 MEDICALLY INCAPACITATED TO

29:24 LIKE, UH, RETURN BACK TO THE

29:26 WORKFORCE.

29:26 SO I THINK THEY'VE BEEN VERY

29:28 SUCCESSFUL ON THAT AT.

29:28 THE GYM.

29:29 I DO BELIEVE I DO.

29:30 BELIEVE IN THE BUT THAT THAT

29:32 HAS BEEN CUT THOUGH, HASN'T IT?

29:34 THE HEALTH AND WELLNESS ASPECT

29:35 OF THE POLICE?

29:38 UH, NOT THAT I'M AWARE OF BUT I

29:40 CAN CERTAINLY FOLLOW UP ON

29:41 THAT.

29:42 I BELIEVE FOR THE POLICE AND

29:43 FIRE THE HEALTH AND WELLNESS UM

29:46 TYPE PROGRAMS HAVE BEEN HAVE

29:48 BEEN CUT.

29:50 UM.

29:52 SO SO.

29:52 WHAT ARE WE.

29:53 DOING TO.

29:53 TO ENSURE.

29:54 THAT POLICE OFFICERS THAT ARE

29:56 WORKING 16 HOURS A DAY

29:58 CONSISTENTLY HAVE THE RIGHT

30:00 HAVE THE RIGHT TIME OFF AND

30:02 SLEEP SO THAT THEY CAN BE

30:04 EFFECTIVE ON THEIR JOB?

30:08 I KNOW UH JUST FROM HEARING UH

30:10 TESTIMONY IN PAST THERE ARE

30:11 STRICT RULES AROUND THE NUMBER

30:13 OF HOURS THAT OFFICERS ARE UM

30:16 UH, ARE ELIGIBLE TO WORK AND

30:18 THEY DO UM THEY DO TRACK THAT

30:22 STAY ON TOP OF THAT.

30:23 UM, BUT THE UH BUT IT'S NOT.

30:27 ALL BUT THAT'S NOT WHAT.

30:28 OFFICERS ARE TELLING ME.

30:29 OFFICERS ARE TELLING ME THAT

30:30 THE CONSISTENTLY WORKING 16

30:32 HOUR DAYS AND AND THEN THE THE

30:35 GOING HOME AND THE THEY'RE

30:37 TRYING TO SPEND A LITTLE BIT

30:39 OF TIME WITH THEIR FAMILY THEN

30:39 THEY'RE BACK TO WORK AGAIN.

30:41 THEY THEY'RE TELLING ME IT'S

30:42 IT'S IMPACTING THE HEALTH AND

30:45 WELLNESS OF OFFICERS AND ALSO

30:47 WORK LIFE BALANCE.

30:49 THOSE ARE THOSE ARE ISSUES I

30:50 JUST CAN'T IGNORE.

30:53 UM, THEY'RE IMPORTANT.

30:54 TO ME.

30:58 UH, YEAH.

30:58 COUNCILOR FLYNN SORRY, I JUST I

31:00 WAS GOING TO GIVE YOU SIX

31:01 MINUTES.

31:01 YOU GOT ANOTHER MINUTE LEFT?

31:03 UH, AND THEN I WILL WE'LL ALSO

31:04 BE JOINED BY

31:05 COUNCILOR FITZGERALD.

31:06 YEAH, BUT BUT MR CHAIR, THESE

31:08 ARE THESE ARE ISSUES.

31:09 THAT.

31:10 ARE THESE ARE ISSUES THAT WE

31:11 NEED TO HAVE A.

31:12 SERIOUS DISCUSSION ABOUT AND

31:14 WE'RE NOT.

31:15 DOING THAT WE'RE NOT HAVING A

31:17 CONVERSATION ABOUT WORK LIFE

31:19 BALANCE FOR POLICE OFFICERS,

31:20 HOW WE'RE SUPPORTING POLICE

31:22 OFFICERS.

31:23 UM, JUST BECAUSE WE.

31:25 IGNORE A SUBJECT DOESN'T MEAN

31:26 THE SUBJECT GOES AWAY.

31:30 SO MY MY JOB MY.

31:32 RESPONSIBILITY IS.

31:33 TO ADDRESS THESE ISSUES.

31:34 THAT'S WHAT PEOPLE PUT ME IN

31:35 OFFICE FOR TO ASK ASK THE TOUGH

31:37 QUESTIONS AND AND MAKE CHANGES.

31:41 SO I'M.

31:42 STILL.

31:42 NOT CONFIDENT FROM THIS

31:45 CONVERSATION THAT WE HAVE A

31:46 PLAN TO ADDRESS HEALTH AND

31:48 WELLNESS PROGRAMS, THAT WE HAVE

31:50 A PLAN TO ADDRESS 16 HOUR WORK

31:52 DAYS.

31:53 AND I THINK IT'S UNFAIR TO

31:55 POLICE OFFICERS THAT WE'RE

31:57 PUTTING THEM IN THIS PARTICULAR

31:59 SITUATION WORKING 16 HOURS A

32:02 DAY AND THEN KNOWING THAT THAT.

32:04 WHEN WHEN AN ISSUE.

32:06 DOES COME COME UP.

32:07 THEY'RE NOT GOING TO BE.

32:09 SUPPORTED AT BOSTON CITY HALL

32:10 WE ALL KNOW THAT.

32:12 THIS THAT THIS THIS CITY

32:14 COUNCIL IS DONE FOR THE FOR THE

32:15 MOST PART DON'T RESPECT THE

32:16 WORK THE POLICE OFFICERS.

32:18 DO SO I DO WE I DO THINK WE WE

32:21 NEED TO HAVE A.

32:22 SERIOUS CONVERSATION ABOUT IT.

32:23 I RESPECT THE WORK JIM IS DOING

32:25 BUT I WISH I COULD GET ANSWERS

32:28 TO THIS.

32:29 THANK YOU, MR CHAIR.

32:29 OKAY.

32:30 THANK YOU, COUNCILOR FLYNN.

32:32 I JUST JUST MAYBE TO CLARIFY A

32:34 LITTLE BIT ABOUT TODAY'S

32:36 HEARING.

32:36 SO, UH BUT DIRECTOR.

32:38 WILLIAMSON, CAN YOU.

32:39 JUST EXPLAIN?

32:40 SO WE VOTED IN MAY TO APPROVE

32:43 2% INCREASES THAT WERE, UH, YOU

32:46 KNOW, TAKEN MONEY OUT OF THE,

32:47 UH, THE RESERVE.

32:48 NOW WE'RE VOTING AGAIN.

32:51 IS THIS ON?

32:52 IS THIS TO MAINTAIN THAT 2%

32:54 INCREASE THAT WE VOTED BACK IN

32:55 MAY, IS THIS AN ADDITIONAL 2%

32:58 INCREASE?

32:58 JUST JUST CAN YOU.

32:59 EXPLAIN THE MATH.

33:01 COUNCIL I THINK WHAT YOU SAID

33:02 UH, BEFORE IS EVEN THOUGH THE

33:04 CONTRACTS EXPIRE, THE THE

33:06 EXISTING TERMS OF THE CONTRACT

33:07 CONTINUE AND SO THE THE THE

33:09 WAGE BENEFITS THAT WERE

33:10 APPROVED BY COUNCIL IN MAY, UM

33:13 ARE IN PLACE IN UH THE OFFICE

33:16 THIS IS JUST TO MAKE SURE THAT

33:17 THE POLICE DEPARTMENT'S 527

33:18 BUDGET HAS SUFFICIENT RESOURCES

33:20 TO COVER THOSE.

33:21 YEAH, I.

33:22 UNDERSTAND THAT, BUT THAT

33:23 DOESN'T MEAN YOU.

33:23 DON'T HAVE A A.

33:24 SERIOUS CONVERSATION.

33:26 MR CHAIR, ABOUT ABOUT HEALTH

33:28 AND WELLNESS.

33:29 OF POLICE OFFICERS.

33:30 YOU STILL ADDRESS THE ISSUE

33:32 EVEN.

33:33 THOUGH WE HAD A CONVERSATION

33:34 IN MAY, IT'S.

33:35 EVEN MORE.

33:35 IMPORTANT NOW TO HAVE THAT

33:37 CONVERSATION TO LEARN ABOUT.

33:39 WHAT WHAT TOOK.

33:40 PLACE IN MAY TO THE PRESENT

33:42 OF HOW WE'RE.

33:42 SUPPORTING POLICE OFFICERS.

33:43 BECAUSE WE.

33:44 HAD A HEARING.

33:45 UM, A BUDGET HEARING ON IT SIX

33:47 MONTHS AGO AND AS IF THAT'S

33:49 THAT'S THAT'S NECESSARY AND

33:52 THAT WILL COVER US TODAY.

33:53 I DON'T I DON'T AGREE WITH

33:54 THAT.

33:54 I THINK WE HAVE TO HAVE A

33:55 SERIOUS CONVERSATION AND IT

33:57 DOESN'T SEEM LIKE.

33:58 YOU WANT.

33:59 TO ASK THOSE TOUGH

34:00 QUESTIONS, MR CHAIR.

34:01 NO.

34:02 OKAY.

34:02 WELL, UH, I.

34:03 YOU KNOW THAT WE'RE HAVING A

34:05 CONVERSATION ABOUT STAFFING AT

34:08 THE POLICE DEPARTMENT AND UH,

34:11 YOU KNOW, ISSUES OF OF OF HOW

34:13 OUR POLICE OFFICERS ARE DOING

34:16 THEIR HEALTH AND WELLNESS.

34:17 I JUST I DON'T THINK THAT'S THE

34:19 SUBJECT OF TODAY'S MEETING,

34:20 BUT.

34:21 MR CHAIR.

34:21 IT'S.

34:22 NOT IT'S NOT GOING TO HAPPEN.

34:23 IT'S NOT GOING TO GET

34:24 SCHEDULED.

34:25 THAT'S WHY I'M ASKING THESE.

34:26 QUESTIONS BECAUSE UM, OUR

34:28 COLLEAGUES DON'T WANT TO HAVE

34:29 A.

34:30 SERIOUS CONVERSATION ABOUT

34:31 WHAT'S HAPPENING IN THE POLICE

34:33 DEPARTMENT.

34:33 SO I HAVE TO TAKE THE

34:34 OPPORTUNITY TO ASK QUESTIONS

34:37 AND GET IT ON THE RECORD THAT

34:38 I'M NOT HAPPY.

34:39 WITH THE WAY WE'RE WAITING.

34:40 POLICE OFFICERS.

34:41 WE'RE TREATING THEM WITH

34:42 DISRESPECT, MISTER.

34:43 CHAIR, AND PEOPLE REMAIN

34:44 SILENT.

34:45 OKAY.

34:46 NOTED COUNCILOR FLYNN.

34:48 COUNCILOR MURPHY, I'M GOING TO

34:50 GIVE YOU, UH, SIX MINUTES.

34:52 THANK YOU.

34:52 COME FIRST.

34:54 JUST WANT TO THANK ALL OF OUR

34:56 FIRST RESPONDERS, OUR POLICE

34:57 OFFICERS.

34:58 WE HAVE BEEN PATTING OURSELVES

35:00 ON THE BACK FOR HAVING SUCH A

35:02 SAFE AND CROWDED, FUN SUMMER.

35:05 BUT IT DOES NOT GO UNNOTICED BY

35:07 ME THAT IT WAS BECAUSE OUR

35:08 FIRST RESPONDERS STEPPED UP AND

35:10 WERE AT ALL OF THE EVENTS

35:11 ACROSS THE CITY AND WORKING A

35:13 LOT OF OVERTIME TO MAKE SURE

35:15 THAT WE IMPLEMENTED THE PLANS

35:18 THAT THEY WERE EXPECTED TO

35:20 FOLLOW THROUGH ON.

35:20 SO THANK YOU TO THAT.

35:22 I ALSO WANT TO ASK THANK YOU

35:24 FOR BEING HERE, JIM.

35:25 BUT WHEN WE'RE TALKING ABOUT A

35:28 CONTRACT IS LABOR RELATIONS ON

35:29 THIS HEARING OR WERE THEY

35:30 INVITED?

35:35 I BELIEVE THAT'S A QUESTION FOR

35:36 THE FOR ME.

35:38 UH SO UH.

35:39 WHOEVER CAN ANSWER THAT.

35:40 YEAH NO I BE BECAUSE WE'RE

35:42 COVERING THE SAME UH, SUBJECT

35:45 MATTER THAT WE COVERED IN MAY.

35:47 UH.

35:48 I DO FEEL THOSE THINGS.

35:49 COME UP BECAUSE I HAVE SOME

35:50 SPECIFIC QUESTIONS THAT MAY BE

35:51 NEW INFORMATION FROM THE LAST

35:53 TIME AND IF WE'RE GOING TO VOTE

35:56 TO KEEP THIS CONTRACT GOING

35:57 BECAUSE WE COULD VOTE NO AND

36:01 ASK FOR MORE IF NEEDED.

36:02 SO I BELIEVE THAT, UM, THAT'S

36:05 NECESSARY AND I DO WANT TO

36:06 THANK MAYBE JEAN IS ON BUT I DO

36:08 KNOW THAT PRESIDENT GRIFFIN

36:10 FROM THE UM DETECTIVES UNION IS

36:13 ON.

36:13 HE'S NOT A PANELIST NOW, BUT HE

36:15 DID HOP ON TO LISTEN.

36:16 HE WAS NOT AWARE OF THIS

36:17 MEETING.

36:18 SO THANK YOU FOR BEING HERE.

36:19 UM, CURRENTLY WE'RE BUDGETED

36:22 FOR 283 DETECTIVES AND I

36:27 BELIEVE WE ONLY HAVE 238.

36:29 SO WE'RE SHORT ABOUT 45

36:31 DETECTIVES RIGHT NOW AND

36:33 DETECTIVES JIM I'M NOT SURE IF

36:34 YOU KNOW THIS BUT IF YOU CAN

36:35 HELP ANSWER THIS OUR CIVIL

36:37 SERVICE PATROL OFFICERS AND

36:38 THEY CAN SUPPLEMENT THE POLICE

36:40 FORCE AND THAT WE ALSO HAD BEEN

36:45 TOLD AND THE DETECTIVES HAVE

36:47 BEEN TOLD THAT WE WERE GOING TO

36:49 HAVE A CLASS OF 25 GOING IN THE

36:51 ACADEMY THIS MONTH AND THIS

36:52 MONTH IS ALMOST OVER.

36:54 DO WE KNOW ONE THAT CLASS

36:55 OF NEW DETECTIVES WILL BE

36:57 TRAINED BECAUSE IT SEEMS LIKE

36:59 WE'VE DELAYED IT AND WE KNOW

37:01 WE'RE ALREADY SHORT 45

37:03 DETECTIVES.

37:04 I'D HAVE TO GET BACK TO, UH,

37:06 COUNSELOR ON THE ON THE UH ON

37:09 UH WHEN THEY SHOULD HAVE UH,

37:11 RATE AND UH, PLACE DETECTIVES

37:13 INTO UH.

37:15 UM IF WE FOLLOW ANY SORT

37:17 OF BUDGET SORT OF RECRUIT

37:18 CLASSES FOR, UH, PATROL

37:20 OFFICERS AND THINGS.

37:22 BUT DETECTIVE, SORT OF I'D HAVE

37:23 TO FIND OUT FROM THE POLICE

37:25 DEPARTMENT.

37:26 UM, WE'RE ARE YOU TOLD WHEN

37:28 CLASSES ARE BUDGETED BUT THEN

37:30 CANCELED?

37:31 DO YOU KNOW OR IF.

37:32 YOU ALSO.

37:33 TOLD LIKE A CERTAIN NUMBER

37:35 OF BUDGETED BUT WE'RE UNDER

37:36 THAT.

37:37 HOW DO YOU GET NOTIFIED

37:38 OF THAT?

37:38 UH, WE WE IT GOES THROUGH THE

37:41 HIRING PROCESS WHERE THEY'RE

37:43 SAYING THEY WANT TO PROMOTE A

37:44 CERTAIN AMOUNT OF DETECTIVES,

37:46 UM.

37:47 UH.

37:48 OF RATE THEM AS DETECTIVES.

37:49 THERE IS A PROCESS THAT UM I

37:52 THINK YOU RATE IT AND THEN UH,

37:54 SIX MONTHS THEN YOU'RE

37:57 OFFICIALLY LIKE A DETECTIVE

37:58 AFTER THE TRAINING PERIOD.

38:00 AND I'M MAKING AN ASSUMPTION I

38:02 WISH SOMEONE WAS HERE WHO COULD

38:03 ANSWER ME PROPERLY.

38:04 BUT I WANT TO PUT THIS QUESTION

38:06 ON THE RECORD.

38:07 ARE WE PURPOSELY NOT TRAINING

38:10 DETECTIVES BECAUSE WE'RE LOW ON

38:12 PATROL OFFICERS?

38:14 AND IF PATROL OFFICERS ARE

38:18 PROMOTED, WHICH THEY SHOULD BE

38:19 WHEN THEY STUDY AND DESERVE

38:21 THESE PROMOTIONS BUT THEY'RE

38:22 CHOOSING NOT TO PROMOTE THEM

38:24 BECAUSE IT WOULD TAKE THEM AWAY

38:25 FROM.

38:26 BEING SLOTS IN THE DIFFERENT,

38:28 YOU KNOW, DEPARTMENTS ACROSS

38:30 THE CITY WHERE WE'RE ALREADY

38:31 UNDERSTAFFED BY POLICE OFFICERS

38:33 BECAUSE THAT WOULD BE

38:34 CONCERNING TO ME MY FOR NOT

38:36 ALLOWING OFFICERS WHO HAVE

38:38 STUDIED AND WORKED HARD TO GET

38:40 PROMOTED BECAUSE WE CAN'T

38:41 AFFORD TO LOSE THEM AS OFFICERS

38:45 PATROLMEN.

38:46 SO WE'RE GOING TO NOT ALLOW

38:47 THEM TO BE DETECTIVES IN THAT

38:49 CASE DO YOU KNOW DO WE PRORATE

38:50 THEIR RAISES IF WE KNOW THAT

38:53 THEY WERE NOT PROMOTED NOT BY

38:57 THEIR CHOICE BUT WE JUST

38:58 COULDN'T AFFORD TO.

39:00 I'M NOT SURE, COUNSELOR.

39:02 I DON'T THINK SO.

39:03 BUT OKAY.

39:04 AND THIS JUST CONFUSING RIGHT

39:07 TO KNOW WHAT CAN THE PATROL

39:09 OFFICERS DO AND IF WE'RE

39:11 CHOOSING NOT TO PROMOTE THEM

39:12 THEN THAT WOULD BE A CONCERN.

39:14 UM, THEN ARE YOU EXPECTING TO

39:15 VOTE ON THIS WEDNESDAY?

39:18 UH, I I WOULD LIKE TO, UH YOU

39:22 KNOW, IF YOU I GUESS IF YOU

39:24 HAVE QUESTIONS.

39:25 GET SOME ANSWERS BEFORE THEN

39:26 ARE YOU CONFIDENT YOU COULD.

39:27 YEP.

39:27 I CAN CERTAINLY, UH, REACH OUT

39:31 TO UH WE CAN.

39:33 WE CAN TRY TO GET ANSWERS ON

39:35 THESE ON WEDNESDAY AND, UH, YOU

39:37 KNOW, IF IT LOOKS LIKE IT WOULD

39:39 JUST TAKE AN EXTRA WEEK, YOU

39:41 KNOW, TO GET THE ANSWERS I CAN

39:42 WE CAN VOTE ON IT.

39:44 I THINK.

39:44 IT'S UP TO YOU AS THE CHAIR,

39:46 BUT WOULD YOU ALLOW, UM.

39:48 THE PRESIDENT OF THE UNION TO

39:51 ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS?

39:53 I KNOW HE'S ON THIS HEARING NOW

39:54 HE'S LISTENING.

39:56 UH HUH UH I SUPPOSE YEAH, I

39:59 THINK THAT'S FINE.

40:00 WHY DON'T WE WHEN WE GET

40:01 THROUGH THIS, UH UH, WITH

40:04 MR WILLIAMSON AND WE CAN BRING

40:05 ON, YOU KNOW, THERE'S PUBLIC

40:07 TESTIMONY OR WE CAN BRING YOU

40:08 KNOW.

40:10 UNFORTUNATELY THAT'S WHAT

40:11 HAPPENED A COUPLE OF WEEKS AGO

40:12 ALSO COUNCIL FLYNN REMEMBER

40:13 WHEN IT WAS LARRY SPOKE AS

40:16 PUBLIC TESTIMONY, NOT AS A

40:17 PANELIST BECAUSE HE WASN'T ALSO

40:19 INVITED TO BE PART OF THE

40:20 CONVERSATION.

40:21 I JUST THINK IT WOULD MAKE LIFE

40:23 EASIER FOR EVERYONE AND SHOW

40:25 THE RESPECT TO OUR UNION

40:26 PRESIDENT TO REPRESENT OUR CITY

40:28 WORKERS.

40:29 UM THANK YOU.

40:30 I HAVE NO OTHER QUESTIONS BUT I

40:31 HOPE WE CAN GET THESE QUESTIONS

40:33 ANSWERED AND WE CAN RESPECT THE

40:34 UNION LEADERS WHO SHOW UP EVERY

40:36 DAY FOR OUR CITY EMPLOYEES.

40:38 THANK YOU.

40:39 OKAY.

40:40 UM.

40:42 UH, YES.

40:43 COUNCILOR FITZGERALD OR IS

40:44 RIGHT.

40:45 UH.

40:46 JUST, UH SIX MINUTES.

40:50 UM UH YES.

40:52 I'LL, UH I'LL FILL OUT JUST AT

40:54 THE TOP BUT WE HAD A HEARING IN

40:56 MAY ON THIS CONTRACT CONTRACTS

40:58 EXPIRED BUT, UH, TRYING TO

41:01 PROVIDE THE SAME WAGE INCREASE

41:03 SO THERE IS UH, DOCKETS TO, UH,

41:05 PULL MONEY FROM THE RESERVES

41:07 FOR THE DETECTIVES AND THE

41:09 DETECTIVE SUPERIOR OFFICERS.

41:11 UH, AND THAT'S THAT'S WHY WE'RE

41:14 SORT OF HAVING A MORE TRUNCATED

41:17 PROCESS OR AT LEAST THAT'S THAT

41:19 WAS THE IDEA.

41:20 UH, AND WE NEED WE'RE GOING TO

41:21 HEAR FROM, UH.

41:23 YOU KNOW.

41:23 SOME UH, UNION, UH,

41:26 REPRESENTATION BUT SO SIX

41:28 MINUTES.

41:30 THANK YOU SIR.

41:30 UH.

41:31 FIRST I JUST WANT TO GET

41:32 EVERYONE WITH SOME NUMBERS.

41:33 AND I WANT YOU TO MAKE SURE

41:34 YOU GOT YOUR PEN OUT.

41:35 UM, AS OF.

41:37 AUGUST 26TH, 2026.

41:38 NEXT HAS SAID WE HAVE, UH, FOR

41:41 PATROLMEN WE HAVE 1423

41:45 PATROLMAN.

41:46 AS OF THE END OF AUGUST.

41:47 ALL RIGHT.

41:48 UH, WE HAVE 2050 ALL SWORN

41:53 INCLUDING COMMAND STAFF.

41:55 UH.

41:55 SO IF YOU INCLUDE THE

41:56 COMMAND STAFF.

41:57 THAT NUMBER JUMPS FROM.

42:00 UH 1423 TO 2050.

42:02 AND THEN WE HAVE.

42:03 241 UH DETECTIVES.

42:06 UH, THERE IS NO MINIMUM NUMBER

42:08 FOR DETECTIVES, BUT WE ARE.

42:11 SUPER SHORT ON DETECTIVE, SO I

42:12 KNOW WE DON'T HAVE A MINIMUM

42:14 BUT 241 UM, AND I THINK AARON,

42:18 THIS RELATES WHEN YOU GUYS WHEN

42:19 WE TRY TO DETECT THAT THEY'RE

42:21 SAYING HEY, WE'RE STRETCHED

42:22 THIN.

42:22 UH, 241 BUT NOT NEARLY ENOUGH.

42:25 SO JUST WANTED TO, UM, GET

42:27 THOSE NUMBERS OUT THERE AS

42:28 OF THE END OF AUGUST SO WE AT

42:30 LEAST CAN WORK OFF SOMETHING

42:31 AND THAT'S FROM THAT IS FROM HR

42:34 UM, THAT WE GOT THOSE FOR THE

42:36 APD.

42:37 UH, JIM, THANK YOU VERY MUCH

42:38 FOR BEING HERE, MAN.

42:39 UH, I JUST REALLY HAVE A, UM A

42:42 QUESTION.

42:43 I KNOW BEN JUST SORT OF GAVE

42:44 ME THE RUNDOWN.

42:45 THE CHAIR JUST GAVE ME THE

42:46 RUNDOWN, BUT, UM, SO IT

42:48 EXPIRED.

42:50 WE CONTINUE.

42:50 OFF THE FORMER CONTRACT.

42:52 IT IS THIS 2% RAISE.

42:54 IT'S CONTINUING.

42:56 SO WHAT WE'RE VOTING ON NOW

42:57 JUST MAKE SURE THAT THEY ARE

42:58 GOOD.

42:59 UP UNTIL WHEN?

43:00 UP UNTIL WE HAVE A NEW

43:02 CONTRACTOR UP UNTIL THE NEXT

43:04 FISCAL YEAR.

43:05 IS THIS JUST FOR THE ENTIRE

43:07 YEAR.

43:07 YOU THIS IS TO BASICALLY MAKE

43:09 UH TO INCREASE THE POLICE

43:10 DEPARTMENT'S HAVE FOR 27 BUDGET

43:12 TO MAKE SURE IT HAS THE

43:14 RESOURCES IN IT UH FOR THAT.

43:15 CONTRACT AND DURING THAT TIME

43:18 WE ARE PLANNING TO WE'LL BE

43:20 NEGOTIATING FOR THE NEXT

43:22 CONTRACT TO TAKE EFFECT.

43:23 DO WE HAVE A TIMELINE OF IF

43:25 THAT WILL END?

43:26 WILL THAT BE RESOLVED PRIOR TO

43:29 FY 27 TO TO UH.

43:32 I'M NOT SURE ON THE TIMING

43:34 OF THE OF THE NEGOTIATIONS UH.

43:36 BUT BUT.

43:37 OKAY BUT SO WE'RE WE'RE

43:39 BASICALLY DOING THIS TO MAKE

43:40 SURE THERE'S MONEY FOR JULY 1ST

43:42 UP UNTIL JULY OR JUNE.

43:46 30TH 2027.

43:46 EXACTLY.

43:47 OKAY.

43:49 UM ALL RIGHT.

43:51 UH YEAH.

43:51 NO, I THINK THAT'S I DON'T HAVE

43:53 ANY FURTHER QUESTIONS ON WHAT

43:54 WAS ASKED.

43:55 UM, IT'S UH THANK YOU FOR

43:56 HELPING ME UNDERSTAND SORT

43:57 OF THE TIMELINE, UH, AND WHAT

43:59 WE GOT HERE AND I ACTUALLY

44:01 WOULD LOVE TO HEAR FROM IF

44:02 THERE IF THERE IS UNION.

44:04 LEADERSHIP HERE ON THE CALL FOR

44:05 TESTIMONY.

44:06 UM, I THINK IT WOULD JUST BE

44:07 GREAT TO GET THEIR TAKE, UH,

44:08 THEIR SIDE OF THINGS.

44:09 SO, UM, THANK YOU ALL FOR FOR

44:12 ALLOWING FOR THAT AND I LOOK

44:13 FORWARD TO HEARING FROM THEM.

44:14 THANK YOU CHAIR.

44:15 YEAH.

44:15 THANK YOU,

44:16 COUNCILOR FITZGERALD.

44:17 UH, I JUST UH SO I GUESS, UH,

44:20 DIRECTOR WILLIAMSON IT'S A, UH

44:22 DO YOU KNOW, IN THE NEW

44:24 CONTRACT, ARE THERE, UM THERE

44:26 ANY CHANGES FOR HEALTH CARE?

44:29 UM, YOU KNOW, I KNOW WE HEAR

44:31 HOW HEALTH CARE COSTS.

44:32 ARE INCREASING.

44:36 I'M NOT SEEING ANYTHING NOTED

44:39 ON THE SUMMARIES, COUNSELOR.

44:41 OKAY.

44:42 UM.

44:43 BUT I WOULD DEFER THAT.

44:44 OKAY.

44:45 UH, AND THEN IN TERMS OF THE

44:47 TIMING, UH, CAN YOU JUST

44:49 EXPLAIN LIKE IF WE HOLD OFF ON

44:52 VOTING LIKE WHAT?

44:53 WHAT IS THE WHY IS THIS BEING

44:55 PUT UP NOW AND.

44:56 RIGHT RIGHT.

44:58 LIKE UM, YOU KNOW ON LIKE SORT

45:00 OF LIKE A THE ORIGINAL 1ST MAY

45:02 THAT THAT.

45:04 UH KICKS OFF THE ABILITY TO

45:05 ACTUALLY EXECUTE AND GIVE THE

45:06 WAGE INCREASE THE WAGE

45:08 INCREASES ARE HAVE ALREADY

45:10 HAPPENED AND THIS IS REALLY

45:11 JUST A CORRECTION OR OF ABOUT A

45:13 527 BUDGET TO MAKE SURE THAT

45:15 IT'S.

45:15 THE RIGHT VALUE.

45:16 TO UH, COVER THESE COSTS.

45:19 OKAY.

45:19 UM, AND UH YEAH, I JUST

45:22 FOLLOWING UP ON

45:24 COUNCILOR FITZGERALD'S POINT I

45:25 KNOW IN MAY WE TALKED ABOUT.

45:26 JUST FOR MY COLLEAGUES I THINK

45:28 IT WAS THAT, UH WE HEARD THAT.

45:31 THE DEPARTMENT IS SHORT STAFFED

45:33 OF APPROXIMATELY 45 DETECTIVES

45:35 UH, BACK THEN.

45:36 SO IT SOUNDS SIMILAR UH UH,

45:40 NUMBERS.

45:41 UM, OKAY, I I WE I'M FINE.

45:45 IF THERE IS ANY REPRESENTATION

45:48 WE CAN, UH, SORT OF SET UP UH,

45:51 YOU KNOW, A SECOND PANEL HERE

45:53 AGAIN IF PEOPLE HAVE SOME

45:56 QUESTIONS UM, AND I DON'T KNOW

46:00 IF UNION REPRESENTATION WANTS

46:02 TO WHAT'S WHAT'S THE SUBJECT

46:03 THEMSELVES TO THAT BUT, UM,

46:05 DOES ANYONE ELSE HAVE ANY

46:06 QUESTIONS FOR DIRECTOR

46:08 WILLIAMSON?

46:09 YEAH, I GUESS WE'LL GO IN

46:10 ORDER.

46:11 UH, COUNCILOR FLYNN.

46:13 MR CHAIR, UH.

46:15 I YOU KNOW, I SAID AT THE

46:17 BEGINNING I WOULD LIKE TO.

46:18 HEAR DIRECTLY FROM THE THE

46:20 POLICE OFFICERS AND THE UNION.

46:22 UNION LEADERSHIP.

46:23 UM, RESPECT THEM.

46:26 UH, WANT TO HEAR WHAT THEY HAVE

46:27 TO SAY SO I DON'T HAVE ANY

46:29 QUESTIONS.

46:29 I'D RATHER I'D RATHER USE MY

46:30 TIME TO HEAR FROM, UM, THE

46:32 POLICE OFFICERS AND THE UNION

46:34 UNION MEMBERS.

46:35 OKAY.

46:36 UH, COUNCILOR FLYNN OR

46:38 COUNCILOR FITZGERALD?

46:39 UM, SAME.

46:39 I'M LOOKING FORWARD TO THE NEXT

46:41 PANEL.

46:41 THANK YOU, THANK YOU.

46:42 OKAY.

46:43 UH, OKAY.

46:46 UH, THANK YOU, DIRECTOR

46:48 WILLIAMSON.

46:50 UH UH, KIRISHIMA I DON'T KNOW.

46:53 UM YOU.

46:54 I'VE PROMOTED MR GRIFFIN AS A

46:56 PANELIST SO YOU CAN CALL ON

46:57 HIM.

46:57 OKAY.

46:58 UH, YEAH.

47:00 UH UM.

47:02 UH, YES.

47:02 BOB GRIFFIN, YOU'RE HERE I

47:04 GUESS, UH, IF.

47:06 YOU YOU HAVE ANYTHING YOU WANT

47:07 TO SAY?

47:08 YOU GOT A COUPLE MINUTES?

47:10 UH, AND THEN WE'LL, UH WE HAVE

47:12 THREE COUNSELORS HERE IF THEY

47:13 HAVE QUESTIONS FOR YOU.

47:15 UH, UM.

47:17 WE'LL GO FROM THERE.

47:18 SO, UH, I GUESS THE FLOOR IS

47:20 YOURS.

47:22 WELL.

47:23 THANK YOU FOR, UH, THE

47:25 COUNCIL MURPHY, UH, FOR

47:25 INVITING MEJIA.

47:26 UH, I APPRECIATE IT.

47:28 UH, I JUST I GOT AN I GOT IN

47:30 LATE UM, TO THE CONVERSATION

47:32 HERE A COUPLE OF THINGS WE I

47:34 THINK WE ARE ABOUT 238 TO 241

47:37 DETECTIVES RIGHT NOW WE'RE

47:38 BUDGET FOR 283.

47:40 THEY'RE TALKING ABOUT PUTTING A

47:41 CLASS OF DETECTIVES IN I THINK

47:43 IT MR WILLIAMSON WAS SAYING HE

47:44 WAS SAYING MAYBE ABOUT SIX

47:46 MONTHS THAT IT'S ONLY A MONTH

47:47 TO TRAIN DETECTIVES.

47:48 THEY GET OUT AND THEN THEY CAN

47:50 BE, UM, A DETECTIVE.

47:51 THE SIX MONTHS IS FOR SUPERIOR

47:53 DETECTIVES.

47:54 SO IF THE, UM A SERGEANT, UH,

47:57 GETS PUT INTO A UNIT, UH, THEY

47:59 HAVE TO STAY IN THAT, YOU KNOW,

48:00 FOR SIX MONTHS AND THEN THE

48:01 UNIT UM, INVESTIGATIVE UNIT

48:04 THEY'LL PUT THEM INTO THE UNIT

48:05 FOR SIX MONTHS, THEY'LL RATE

48:06 THEM.

48:06 DETECTIVE, DON'T, UH, SERGEANT

48:08 DETECTIVE LIEUTENANT.

48:09 DETECTIVE CAPTAIN DETECTIVE.

48:10 UH, THINGS OF THAT NATURE.

48:13 UH, SO WE'RE LOOKING TO GET YOU

48:16 KNOW, EVEN WITH THE CLASS OF 25

48:18 THAT POSSIBLY WILL BE GOING IN

48:19 OCTOBER THAT WE WERE TOLD

48:20 SEPTEMBER THEN GOT MOVE TO

48:22 OCTOBER.

48:23 NOT NOW.

48:24 UH, SO IF IT GOES IN

48:25 OCTOBER NOW YOU'RE TALKING LATE

48:26 NOVEMBER THAT THEY'RE GOING TO

48:28 WE'RE GOING TO GET UH SOME

48:29 RELIEF AND I JUST WANT TO SAY

48:31 CASTLE MURPHY KIND OF TOUCHED

48:32 ON THIS WE HAVE 238 TO 241

48:35 RIGHT.

48:35 BUT AND THE PATROLMEN ARE DOWN

48:36 A LITTLE BIT.

48:37 WE DID A FOIA REQUEST THROUGH,

48:39 UH, HUMAN RESOURCES WHERE ABOUT

48:40 THAT WITH THE SAME OH, THAT THE

48:42 PATROLMAN RIGHT WHERE THEY WERE

48:43 ABOUT FIVE YEARS AGO AND STILL

48:45 UNDERSTAFFED.

48:45 DEFINITELY.

48:46 UH, BUT WE ARE 50 ALMOST COMING

48:50 UP ON 50 BELOW WHERE WE WERE AT

48:52 UH 5 OR 6 YEARS AGO.

48:54 THE CASELOADS ARE GETTING

48:55 HIGHER BECAUSE OF THE YOU KNOW

48:57 ,THEY THINK OF WHAT HAS

48:58 CHANGED IN THE LAST YOU KNOW,

48:59 WITH AI AND WITH WITH UM YOU

49:01 KNOW, THE CAMERA STUFF THAT

49:02 WE'VE UM OUR MEMBERS HAVE TO GO

49:04 INTO AND SEARCH ALL THIS ALL

49:06 THIS FOOTAGE, ALL THIS DATA AND

49:08 CELL PHONES, ALL THAT THERE'S

49:09 SO MANY THINGS NOW WITH

49:10 TECHNOLOGY THAT WE'RE DOING

49:11 DIFFERENTLY.

49:12 SO WE'RE HAVING THE CASELOAD

49:13 THE LARGER THE THE WORK IS

49:15 HARDER NOW AND WE'RE GETTING UM

49:17 WE HAVING LESS DETECTIVE SO THE

49:19 AND IT GOES RIGHT INTO THE

49:22 HEALTH AND WELLNESS OF OUR

49:23 MEMBERS RIGHT.

49:24 THE CASELOAD IS CRAZY BUT WE

49:26 CAN ALSO IF WE HAVE LIKE THE

49:28 PATROLMAN WE SUPPLEMENT THE

49:30 PATROL FORCE ON THIS SHORT WE

49:31 GET ORDERED INTO INTO UNIFORM

49:34 THE PATROLMAN THEY DON'T

49:36 SUPPLEMENT OUR CASELOADS.

49:37 WE WE DO OUR OWN CASELOAD

49:38 BECAUSE YOU KNOW WE'RE READY,

49:40 WE'RE TRAINED AND WE'RE READY

49:41 DETECTIVES.

49:41 SO THAT RIGHT THERE I I WOULD

49:44 SAY THAT THE DEPARTMENT NEEDS

49:45 TO PUT MORE DETECTIVES ON GET

49:46 US BACK UP TO THE 278 TO 83.

49:49 BUT IN TERMS OF HEALTH AND

49:50 WELLNESS, I NOTICED YOU GUYS

49:51 WERE ALL AT THE UM AND IT WAS

49:53 GREAT.

49:54 UH, WE HAD THE US YOU KNOW, THE

49:56 DOG DIAGNOSTIC SERVICES IN LAST

49:58 LAST YEAR YOU GUYS WERE UP IN

50:00 WEST ROXBURY FOR THE

50:02 FIREFIGHTERS LAST WEEK I

50:03 BELIEVE.

50:03 YES I'VE YEP I WAS OUT THERE.

50:06 YOU KNOW I CONGRATULATE YOU FOR

50:07 THAT.

50:07 I CONGRATULATE THEM FOR GETTING

50:08 THAT DONE.

50:09 WE AND THAT'S I THINK FUNDED BY

50:10 THE CITY THROUGH A GRANT WE

50:12 DON'T WHEN WE DO THAT WE HAVE

50:13 THEM IN FOR OUR MEMBERS WE WE

50:16 HAVE TO WE HAVE TO FUNDRAISE

50:18 FOR OUR HEALTH HEALTH

50:19 SCREENINGS.

50:20 SO WE RAISE MONEY AND WE SPEND

50:21 OUR OWN MONEY AS A UNION TO DO

50:22 THAT FOR OUR MEMBERS.

50:23 AND WE'VE DONE ABOUT 300

50:24 MEMBERS IN THE LAST 3 OR 4

50:26 YEARS AND WE FUND AND EVERY

50:27 TIME YOU DO THEM YOU TALK TO ED

50:29 KELLY I SAW WAS THERE IF THE IF

50:30 SAM DILLON EVERY TIME YOU DO

50:32 100 MEMBERS YOU GET ABOUT THREE

50:33 PEOPLE THAT YOU SAVE IN THEIR

50:35 LIVES.

50:36 SO WE'RE SAVING LIVES WHEN WE

50:37 DO THIS BUT UNFORTUNATELY WE

50:39 HAVE TO FUNDRAISE AND THE, UH,

50:42 CREDIT UNION DOWN AT THE FIRST

50:43 RESPONDERS CREDIT UNION HAS

50:44 BEEN GREAT TO US.

50:44 SO WE APPRECIATE WHAT THEY DO

50:46 WITH US.

50:46 BUT IT'S SOMETHING THAT WE

50:48 THINK THE CITY SHOULD DO.

50:49 THIS SHOULD BE A BUDGET IN THE

50:50 CITY UM IN THE BUDGET FOR SOME

50:51 FUNDING FOR SOME FUNDS FOR US

50:53 TO HAVE UH THE HEALTH

50:54 SCREENINGS DONE AS WELL AND

50:56 RATHER THAN HAVE US MAKE A

50:57 RECORD AND RAISE OUR OWN FUNDS

50:58 FOR A BUDGET BECAUSE IT'S LIFE

51:00 SAVING UH, SCREENINGS.

51:02 UH, BUT UM.

51:03 YEAH, I UNDERSTAND THAT JUST

51:05 BECAUSE YOU MISSED THE

51:06 BEGINNING, UH, OF SO WHAT WE'RE

51:08 HERE WE'RE TALKING ABOUT TODAY

51:10 IS THE 2% WAGE INCREASES THAT

51:12 WERE APPROVED, UH, IN MAY.

51:16 YOU KNOW WHERE THOSE DOCKETS

51:17 ARE BEFORE US?

51:19 UH, AND YOU KNOW, I'M ASSUMING

51:22 THAT THE UNION, UH, YOU KNOW,

51:25 PENDING THE RENEGOTIATION OR

51:27 NEGOTIATION OF THE NEW CONTRACT

51:29 WOULD SUPPORT THE THE 2%, YOU

51:32 KNOW, GETTING THE MONEY OUT

51:33 OF THE COLLECTIVE BARGAINING

51:35 RESERVE TO FUND 2% WAGE

51:37 INCREASES FOR YOUR MEMBERS THAT

51:39 THAT'S KIND OF THAT'S WHAT

51:41 WE'RE HERE TO TALK ABOUT.

51:42 I YOU KNOW, I KNOW UH, MY MY

51:44 COLLEAGUES WOULD LIKE TO

51:45 HIGHLIGHT SOME OTHER ISSUES AND

51:47 THERE ARE OTHER ISSUES WITH UH

51:49 WITH YOUR MEMBERS AND WE

51:51 CERTAINLY AS A COUNCIL WE

51:52 SHOULD BE WORKING ON THESE ARE

51:53 ALL WORTHWHILE.

51:54 THINGS TO TALK ABOUT.

51:55 AND THANK YOU FOR

51:56 HIGHLIGHTING THOSE.

51:56 UH, BUT AND I'LL LEAVE IT TO MY

51:59 COLLEAGUES FOR QUESTIONS JUST

52:00 JUST TO GIVE YOU THE THE LEVEL

52:02 SET HERE WE'RE TALKING ABOUT

52:03 DOCKET, UH, DOCKETS THAT WOULD

52:04 TAKE MONEY OUT OF THE

52:05 COLLECTIVE BARGAINING RESERVES

52:06 TO.

52:07 FUND UH, THE WAGES FOR UH, THE

52:11 DETECTIVES BENEVOLENT UH

52:13 SOCIETY AND THE DETECTIVE.

52:14 BENEVOLENT SOCIETY FOR SUPERIOR

52:17 OFFICERS UM.

52:18 SO THAT WE HAD APPROVED LAST

52:19 YEAR.

52:20 BUT, UH, THANK YOU VERY MUCH.

52:22 I'M JUST GOING TO I'M GOING TO

52:23 THROW IT TO MY COLLEAGUES.

52:25 UH UH, YOU KNOW, HOW ABOUT.

52:27 UM YOU KNOW.

52:28 WE'LL GIVE YOU.

52:30 LET'S SEE FOUR MINUTES UH, FOR

52:33 QUESTIONS.

52:33 YOU KNOW, MR CHAIR, SIX

52:35 MINUTES.

52:36 UM SIX MINUTES.

52:37 HE'S HE'S HE'S.

52:38 A.

52:38 UNION PRESIDENT.

52:39 YES, I HEAR YOU.

52:40 UH, WELL, IT'S A SURPRISE THAT,

52:41 UH, WE'RE DOING FOUR MINUTES IF

52:43 YOU HAVE FOLLOW UP QUESTIONS

52:44 WILL.

52:44 COME BACK.

52:46 OKAY.

52:47 WELL.

52:47 I WANT TO SAY THANK YOU TO

52:49 BOB AND, UM, HIS

52:51 PROFESSIONALISM AND HIS

52:52 ADVOCACY FOR HIS MEMBERS.

52:55 UM, HEALTH AND WELLNESS IS AN

52:56 ISSUE WITH.

52:57 WE'VE TALKED.

52:58 ABOUT AND WORKED ON FOR UH FOR

53:00 FOR MANY YEARS I WAS I WAS

53:03 LISTENING TO YOUR CONVERSATION

53:05 AND.

53:06 IT STRUCK ME.

53:08 THAT BASICALLY.

53:09 UNION THE UNION AND MEMBERS ARE

53:12 ALMOST PAYING FOR THEIR OWN

53:15 ASPECTS.

53:15 SOME PARTS OF THEIR HEALTH AND

53:17 WELLNESS.

53:17 IS THAT IS THAT ACCURATE TO.

53:19 SAY BOBBY.

53:21 THAT THAT'S ACCURATE.

53:22 UH, COST OF FUN.

53:23 THANK YOU.

53:23 AND IT'S UM.

53:26 SO SO WE GOT SOME WE GOT SOME

53:28 FUNDRAISING DOING SOME GOLF

53:29 TOURNAMENTS STUFF LIKE THAT BUT

53:31 WE ALSO I THINK WE PAID UH

53:32 MEMBERS.

53:33 PAID AND 60,000 FOR THEIR OWN

53:35 LAST YEAR SCANS FOR THEIR OWN

53:37 UH, SCANS AND UM WE HAD THEM

53:39 OUT TO THE UNION HALL.

53:40 WE BROUGHT THE THE SAME TRUCK

53:41 THAT YOU PROBABLY SAW LAST WEEK

53:43 AT THE WITH THE FIRE.

53:44 WE BROUGHT THEM TO OUR UNION

53:45 HALL AND YEAH, WE PAID FOR YOU

53:48 KNOW, WHATEVER WE COULDN'T

53:49 WHATEVER THE WE HAD LET'S SAY

53:51 50,000 IT COST $100,000.

53:53 WE PAID THE UM THE EXTRA SO

53:54 ABOUT $60,000 LAST YEAR OUT

53:56 OF OUR FUNDS.

53:58 THANK YOU.

53:59 UM THANK YOU.

53:59 THANK YOU FOR THAT ANSWER.

54:01 RESPECT THE ANSWER AS AS A CITY

54:05 WE'RE BETTER THAN THAT.

54:08 HAVING HAVING.

54:09 POLICE OFFICERS AND THEIR

54:10 FAMILIES AND THE UNION AND TO

54:13 TRY TO RAISE MONEY FOR THE

54:16 HEALTH AND WELLNESS FOR THEIR

54:18 MEDICAL NEEDS.

54:20 WHAT WE'RE.

54:21 ASKING THEM BECAUSE IT'S SUCH A

54:23 CRITICAL ISSUE THAT IT'S SO

54:25 IMPORTANT WE'RE ASKING THEM TO

54:26 TO.

54:27 PAY FOR IT PAY FOR.

54:28 IT ON YOUR OWN.

54:29 YOU KNOW.

54:30 THE THE CITY'S NOT GOING TO PAY

54:32 FOR ALL OF IT.

54:33 UM THE YOU KNOW, YOU GOT YOU'RE

54:36 ON THE HOOK FOR SOME OF IT I

54:37 DON'T I DON'T SUPPORT THAT.

54:39 I THINK WHEN WE PUT.

54:40 SOMEONE IN HARM'S WAY FOR AN

54:43 EXTENDED PERIOD OF TIME EIGHT

54:45 HOURS A DAY, 16 HOURS A DAY AND

54:48 OH, BY THE WAY, YOU GUYS HAVE

54:50 TO PAY SOME OF YOUR HEALTH AND

54:51 WELLNESS.

54:52 I DON'T SUPPORT THAT.

54:53 THAT'S NOT THE BOSTON UM, FROM

54:56 UM I'M I'M PRETTY ANGRY ABOUT

54:58 THAT RIGHT NOW AND I KNOW THIS

55:02 THIS CITY COUNCIL DOESN'T

55:04 SUPPORT.

55:04 IT DOESN'T.

55:05 SUPPORT THE RANK AND FILE

55:07 POLICE OFFICERS.

55:07 WHY WHY WHY.

55:09 DO YOU SAY THAT, ED?

55:10 WELL.

55:11 LOOK LISTEN TO WHAT WE JUST

55:13 HEARD.

55:13 THAT THAT THAT POLICE OFFICERS

55:15 ARE PAYING FOR THEIR OWN

55:16 MEDICAL CARE.

55:16 THAT'S PRETTY OUTRAGEOUS.

55:18 THAT'S OUTRAGEOUS.

55:19 THANKFULLY THEY ARE PAYING IT

55:21 THAT THE THE THE THE MEN AND

55:23 WOMEN AND THEIR FAMILIES AND

55:24 THE UNION THEY'RE PAYING IT BUT

55:26 THAT'S THE JOB OF A CITY.

55:27 THAT'S THE JOB OF THE CITY

55:29 GOVERNMENT IN MY OPINION.

55:32 UM I'M EMBARRASSED.

55:34 I'M REALLY EMBARRASSED AS A

55:35 LONGTIME BOSTON RESIDENT

55:37 KNOWING THAT WE'RE NOT

55:40 PROVIDING POLICE OFFICERS AND

55:42 THEIR FAMILIES WITH THE

55:43 CRITICAL HEALTH AND WELLNESS

55:44 VARIOUS SCREENINGS AND I JUST

55:47 CAN'T SIT HERE AND PRETEND

55:49 THAT'S NOT A PROBLEM.

55:51 AND CAN I JUST SAY ONE ONE

55:52 THING?

55:53 SORRY.

55:53 YEAH, YEAH, I.

55:54 BET I MAY HAVE MISSPOKE

55:55 ABOUT THE MONEY THAT THE 50,000

55:57 THAT I THAT WAS THROUGH

55:59 FUNDRAISING THE OTHER 60,000

56:00 WAS FROM OUR FROM OUR OWN

56:02 COFFERS LET'S SAY RIGHT THE

56:03 CITY PAID THE CITY PAY NONE

56:05 OF IT WOULD SAY THAT THEY

56:06 DIDN'T PAY HALF THEY DIDN'T

56:07 THEY PAID NONE OF IT.

56:08 YEAH I.

56:10 I KNOW THAT WAS AN ISSUE MYSELF

56:12 AND JOHN AND ERIN WE.

56:14 WE WORKED ON DURING THE BUDGET

56:16 ON HEALTH AND WELLNESS FOR

56:17 POLICE.

56:18 I THINK WE HAVE TO HAVE A

56:19 SERIOUS CONVERSATION.

56:20 GOING IN.

56:22 THE.

56:22 FUTURE ABOUT.

56:23 WHETHER OR NOT WE ARE GOING.

56:25 TO TREAT POLICE.

56:25 OFFICERS WITH.

56:26 RESPECT OR NOT.

56:27 UM, AND IF WE ARE.

56:29 GOING TO TREAT THEM WITH

56:29 RESPECT WE HAVE TO WE.

56:31 HAVE TO ADDRESS HEALTH AND

56:32 WELLNESS AND SCREENING RELATED

56:34 ISSUES.

56:35 UM.

56:35 HIS HIS.

56:37 A POLICE OFFICER, BOBBY

56:38 GRIFFIN.

56:38 THAT'S DOING EVERYTHING.

56:40 HE CAN FOR HIS MEMBERS AND THE

56:43 CITY OF BOSTON IS NOT STEPPING

56:45 UP UM, TO.

56:46 SUPPORT TO SUPPORT THE MEMBERS

56:48 .

56:48 UM, I'M PRETTY OUTRAGED.

56:50 I'M PRETTY UPSET ABOUT THAT.

56:51 BUT, UM, I'LL I'LL I'LL LEAVE

56:55 IT TO THE NEXT

56:56 COUNCIL COLLEAGUE BECAUSE I'M

56:57 I'M OUT OF TIME, I BELIEVE.

56:58 OKAY.

56:59 YEAH.

56:59 THANK YOU, COUNCILOR FLYNN.

57:00 UH, COUNCILOR MURPHY.

57:02 YES.

57:03 YOU'RE HERE OKAY.

57:04 YEP.

57:04 AND THANK YOU, BOBBY FOR

57:07 HOPPING ON ON SUCH SHORT NOTICE

57:08 .

57:09 AND I THINK IT'S ALWAYS.

57:10 IMPORTANT WE DON'T HAVE ENOUGH

57:13 HEARINGS.

57:14 I BELIEVE AND OFTENTIMES WHEN I

57:17 FILE OR SPONSOR HEARINGS THE

57:18 ADMINISTRATION DOESN'T SHOW UP

57:20 TO ANSWER QUESTIONS.

57:21 SO I'M HAPPY THAT WE CAN GET

57:22 SOME CLARIFYING ANSWERS TO WHAT

57:25 I BELIEVE IS IMPORTANT AND IT

57:26 DOES TIED TO THE BUDGET AND IT

57:28 TIES TO WHAT WE'RE GOING TO

57:29 ADVOCATE TO MAKE SURE WE SEE IN

57:30 OUR BUDGET.

57:32 ANOTHER THING THAT IS

57:34 CONCERNING TO ME IS WHEN WE PIT

57:35 OUR CITY DEPARTMENTS AGAINST

57:37 EACH OTHER, ESPECIALLY OUR

57:38 FIRST RESPONDERS.

57:39 I DO WANT TO TAKE A MOMENT TO

57:40 JUST ACKNOWLEDGE THAT I THINK

57:44 IT'S ALWAYS BEEN TRUE AND YOU

57:46 WOULD KNOW BEING OUT THERE ON

57:47 THE STREETS UM BOBBY BUT OUR

57:49 EMS RECENTLY IN THE NEWS WE'RE

57:51 HEARING A LOT OF EMS BEING

57:54 ATTACKED AND NOT TREATED

57:55 PROPERLY AND MAYBE NOT HAVING

57:56 ALL THE SUPPORT THEY NEED.

57:58 SO I JUST WANT TO MAKE SURE THE

58:00 EMS KNOWS I'M ADVOCATING FOR

58:02 THEIR HEALTH AND WELLNESS AND

58:03 THE SUPPORTS THEY NEED AND WHEN

58:06 THE ONE I BELIEVE POINT $3

58:08 MILLION GRANT WAS NOT RENEWED

58:11 DURING THE BUDGET SEASON A

58:14 PORTION AND THANK YOU TO DANA

58:15 FARBER AND THANK YOU FOR

58:16 OUTSIDE SOURCES BUT ONLY

58:18 100,000 WAS REINSTATED UM 100%

58:23 SUPPORTED AN ADVOCATE THAT OUR

58:25 FIREFIGHTERS HAVE

58:26 CANCER SCREENING OF COURSE.

58:27 BUT WHEN YOU HEAR THAT OUR

58:29 BOSTON POLICE AND OTHER FIRST

58:30 RESPONDERS ARE THEN PAYING FOR

58:32 THEIR OWN, THAT PART OF THE

58:34 STORY WAS LEFT OFF.

58:36 SO I THINK UM, NOW THAT I HAVE

58:38 THAT INFORMATION I'LL MAKE SURE

58:40 WE'RE ADVOCATING TO MAKE SURE I

58:42 DON'T I WILL SAY KNOWLEDGE IS

58:43 POWER.

58:44 SO NOW WE CAN ADVOCATE TO MAKE

58:45 SURE THAT ALL OF OUR FIRST

58:46 RESPONDERS HAVE THE NECESSARY

58:47 SCREENINGS.

58:49 ONE OF THE BENEFITS I LOST WHEN

58:52 I SWITCHED FROM BEEPS TO CITY

58:54 HALL WAS UM, YOU KNOW, I HAD

58:56 DENTAL AND EYE CARE, RIGHT?

58:58 THAT WAS A WONDERFUL BENEFIT

58:59 AND THAT HELPED ME AND MY

59:01 FAMILY, YOU KNOW, IN WONDERFUL

59:04 WAYS.

59:05 SO EACH UNION FIGHTS AND

59:06 ADVOCATES FOR WHAT THEIR

59:08 MEMBERS NEED.

59:08 BUT WHEN YOU'RE DIGGING INTO

59:10 YOUR OWN POCKETS AND ASKING,

59:13 YOU KNOW, CREDIT UNIONS AND

59:15 NEIGHBORS TO, YOU KNOW, SPONSOR

59:17 HOLES AT A GOLF TOURNAMENT AND

59:19 THEN THAT'S NOT JUST GOING FOR

59:21 BEREAVEMENT OR MAKING SURE

59:22 SOMEONE'S WIFE MAYBE YOUR

59:24 HUSBAND AFTER A DEATH GETS, YOU

59:27 KNOW, SOME MEALS OR SUPPORTS

59:28 IT'S GOING TO DIRECT RELATED

59:32 HEALTH ISSUES THAT WE GET ON

59:34 THE JOB RIGHT.

59:35 SO IT'S IMPORTANT THAT WE

59:36 CONTINUE TO ADVOCATE FOR THAT.

59:38 SO THAT'S SOMETHING I'LL WORK

59:39 WITH YOU AND THE OTHER UNION

59:41 LEADERS TO MAKE SURE WE HAVE

59:42 THOSE NUMBERS CORRECT AND

59:44 SUPPORT YOUR MEMBERS.

59:45 SO THANK YOU FOR BEING HERE.

59:47 AND COUNCILOR WEBER I DON'T

59:48 HAVE ANY OTHER QUESTIONS.

59:50 I JUST WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT

59:51 ANY TIME WE APPROVE A NEW

59:53 BUDGET FOR THE NEW CYCLE THAT

59:55 WE GET TO ASK QUESTIONS LIKE

59:57 HOW MANY MEMBERS ARE WE DOWN?

59:58 WHAT DO WE NEED TO DO?

1:00:00 WHEN IS THE NEXT CLASS?

1:00:02 SO I KNOW NOW THAT WE HAVE TO

1:00:04 MAKE SURE AND KIND OF PUSH THAT

1:00:05 THIS NEXT CLASS GOES THROUGH.

1:00:07 IT WAS SUPPOSED TO BE THIS

1:00:08 MONTH GET A DATE, MAKE SURE WE

1:00:11 CAN HOLD THEM TO THAT NEW DATE

1:00:13 IN OCTOBER AND THAT WE PROMOTE

1:00:15 THE MEMBERS RIGHT WITH THE

1:00:16 PROMOTION BECOMES MORE PAY AND

1:00:18 IT'S AN EXPENSIVE CITY TO LIVE

1:00:19 IN AND THOSE MEMBERS DESERVE

1:00:21 THAT PAY.

1:00:22 SO I'M LOOKING FORWARD TO

1:00:23 ADVOCATING FOR THAT.

1:00:24 THANK YOU.

1:00:25 OKAY.

1:00:26 THANK YOU VERY MUCH.

1:00:26 UH, COUNCILOR FITZGERALD.

1:00:28 I THINK YOU'RE STILL ON

1:00:28 HERE.

1:00:29 YEP, YEP.

1:00:30 THANK YOU BUDDY.

1:00:32 THANK YOU FOR BEING HERE.

1:00:34 UM, SO, UH, JUST DOING SOME

1:00:35 MATH FROM WHAT YOU SAID ABOUT

1:00:38 50,000 YOU FUNDRAISED 60,000

1:00:39 COMES OUT OF YOUR OWN COFFERS.

1:00:41 SO FOR FOR, UH, MENTAL HEALTH

1:00:43 AND OVERALL PHYSICAL WELL-BEING

1:00:45 .

1:00:46 UM.

1:00:46 UH, FOR YOUR MEMBERS LIKE IS

1:00:50 110,000 ROUGHLY WOULD THAT BE

1:00:52 LIKE IF WE WOULD HAVE BUDGET

1:00:53 FOR IT?

1:00:53 IS THAT WHAT WE WOULD SORT

1:00:55 OF BUDGET UH PER YEAR IF THE

1:00:57 CITY WOULD HAVE PICK THAT UP

1:00:58 BECAUSE THAT SEEMS LIKE A

1:00:59 NOMINAL OVERALL I DON'T KNOW

1:01:00 MAYBE IF YOU HAVE A BIGGER

1:01:02 NUMBER OR IS THAT JUST LIKE

1:01:03 THAT'S THE BEST YOU KNOW

1:01:04 RAISING 50 AND GIVEN 60.

1:01:07 UM WAS SORT OF LIKE YOU JUST

1:01:09 WRITE A BAND AID IS AS YOU GO

1:01:12 UM AND IT'S PROBABLY A LARGER

1:01:14 NUMBER TO YEAH.

1:01:15 I WOULD JUST.

1:01:16 BUT THANK YOU

1:01:17 COUNCILOR FITZGERALD.

1:01:18 UH NO UH IF IF WE COULD HAVE A

1:01:20 GRANT FOR 100 $120,000 A YEAR

1:01:23 TOWARDS THE HEALTH SCREENING,

1:01:25 THAT WOULD BE AMAZING.

1:01:26 YEAH, THAT WOULD THAT WOULD BE

1:01:27 PERFECT.

1:01:27 THAT WOULD HELP OUR MEMBERS

1:01:28 TREMENDOUSLY.

1:01:30 RIGHT OKAY.

1:01:31 YEAH.

1:01:31 I MEAN IT SEEMS LIKE A NOMINAL

1:01:33 FEE OR A $4.9 BILLION BUDGET TO

1:01:35 MAKE SURE THAT WE'RE WE'RE

1:01:37 TAKING CARE OF THOSE THAT ARE

1:01:38 TAKING CARE OF US.

1:01:39 SO UM.

1:01:39 THAT'S THAT'S SOMETHING THAT WE

1:01:41 SHOULD DEFINITELY LOOK AT.

1:01:42 UM, AT LEAST WITH MY.

1:01:44 FELLOW COUNCILORS.

1:01:44 HERE UM, IN THE NEXT BUDGET

1:01:45 SESSION TO SEE IF WE CAN GET

1:01:47 THAT IN THERE.

1:01:48 UM.

1:01:48 OTHER THAN THAT, I DON'T

1:01:49 THINK I WILL.

1:01:50 I TURN MY TIME OVER TO YOU, BUT

1:01:52 IF THERE'S ANYTHING ELSE THAT

1:01:53 YOU'D LIKE TO PONTIFICATE UPON,

1:01:55 UH, BEFORE STEPPING DOWN, I'LL

1:01:56 GIVE YOU THE REST OF THE, UH,

1:01:57 MY TIME, PLEASE.

1:01:58 THANK YOU.

1:01:59 JUST REAL QUICK.

1:02:00 AND THIS IS A STAT I BRING UP

1:02:01 THAT, UM, THERE'S ALL KINDS

1:02:02 OF DIFFERENT STATS ABOUT, UM,

1:02:03 FIRST RESPONDERS AND I THANK

1:02:05 COUNCILOR MURPHY FOR MENTIONING

1:02:06 EMS BECAUSE THEY DEAL WITH

1:02:07 HAVING SOME OF THE SAME STUFF

1:02:08 THAT WE DEAL WITH BUT AND AND

1:02:10 SOME OF THE UH THIS GUY DOCTOR

1:02:11 HAMM ROCK WHEN WE STARTED THIS

1:02:12 CAMP PROGRAM ABOUT FIVE, MAYBE

1:02:14 EIGHT YEARS AGO ACTUALLY HE UH

1:02:16 HE HAD MENTIONED ONE OF THE ONE

1:02:18 OF THE STATS IT JUST SHOOTS OUT

1:02:19 YOU AT YOU AND I'LL JUST GIVE

1:02:20 YOU THIS QUICK STAT IS THAT.

1:02:22 FOR FIRST RESPONDERS BECAUSE

1:02:23 OF THE STRESS LEVELS I MEAN

1:02:25 THERE'S DIFFERENT STRESS LEVELS

1:02:26 AND DIFFERENT JOBS BUT BECAUSE

1:02:27 OF THE ADRENALINE RUSHES

1:02:28 BETWEEN GOING TO CALLS YOU

1:02:29 COULD HAVE THREE DAYS TO DO

1:02:30 NOTHING AT EMS POLICE FIRE AND

1:02:32 THEN ALL OF A SUDDEN BOOM YOU

1:02:33 GOT THREE CALLS AND YOUR HEART

1:02:34 RATE IS GOING UP AND DOWN GOING

1:02:35 ON THESE CALLS.

1:02:36 SO FOR.

1:02:37 US AND.

1:02:37 IT'S SIMILAR WITH THE EMS

1:02:39 AND FIRE I'M NOT SURE THE EXACT

1:02:40 BUT FOR POLICE OFFICERS YOU

1:02:41 HAVE YOUR FIRST HEART ATTACK AT

1:02:43 48 YEARS OLD TYPICALLY IT FOR

1:02:47 UH A MEMBER OF THE GENERAL

1:02:48 PUBLIC YOUR FIRST HEART ATTACK

1:02:49 IS AT 68 YEARS OLD.

1:02:50 THAT'S WHY THESE SCANS IT

1:02:51 THAT'S ONE OF THE REASONS WHY

1:02:52 THESE SCANS ARE SO NECESSARY

1:02:54 BECAUSE IT LOOKS INTO YOUR, UH,

1:02:56 YOU KNOW, 11 PART ULTRASOUND

1:02:58 AND THEN, UH, FULL BODY SCAN.

1:03:00 SO TELLS YOU WHAT YOU KNOW,

1:03:01 WHAT YOU MIGHT HAVE GOING ON.

1:03:02 AND LIKE I SAID, IT SAVES

1:03:02 LIVES.

1:03:03 SO I APPRECIATE YOU TALKING

1:03:04 ABOUT IT.

1:03:04 I KNOW.

1:03:05 UM.

1:03:06 YOU GUYS ALL YOU KNOW, I

1:03:08 APPRECIATE IT.

1:03:08 THANK YOU.

1:03:11 OKAY.

1:03:12 UH, YEAH.

1:03:13 THANK YOU VERY MUCH.

1:03:14 UM, I GUESS JUST A DETECTIVE

1:03:17 GRIFFIN.

1:03:18 UH, MY QUESTION IS THERE IS

1:03:20 THERE ANY MORE GAPS BETWEEN THE

1:03:23 CONTRACTS BETWEEN THE PATROL

1:03:26 OFFICERS AND THE DETECTIVES?

1:03:28 I KNOW SOME OF THE LATTER, BUT

1:03:29 THE CONTRACT WE APPROVED IN,

1:03:32 UH, IN MAY CLOSED A LOT.

1:03:34 BUT IS THERE ANYTHING ELSE THAT

1:03:36 SORT OF HANGING OUT THERE THAT

1:03:38 ,UM.

1:03:39 YOU KNOW, YOU'RE.

1:03:40 TRYING TO ADDRESS IN.

1:03:41 THE IN THESE NEGOTIATIONS?

1:03:44 UH, I MEAN THERE'S ALWAYS GAPS

1:03:46 SO YOU KNOW, I'M NOT SURE WHAT

1:03:47 THE DIFFERENCES BETWEEN THE

1:03:48 DETECTIVE AND PATROLMAN TWO YOU

1:03:49 .

1:03:50 KNOW.

1:03:50 DIFFERENT JOBS WE ARE CIVIL

1:03:52 SERVICE PATROLMAN.

1:03:53 BUT, UH, I MEAN, IT'S THERE WAS

1:03:55 THERE WAS A CERTAIN PERCENTAGE

1:03:56 AT ONE POINT THAT PERCENTAGE

1:03:57 HAS IT'S SHRUNK A LITTLE BIT

1:03:59 LET'S SAY FROM 7 TO 5%.

1:04:01 SO IF WE GET BACK UP TO 7%

1:04:03 OF WHAT IT WAS BACK YOU KNOW,

1:04:04 1015 YEARS AGO THAT WOULD BE

1:04:06 GREAT.

1:04:06 BUT UM.

1:04:09 IN TERMS OF WE'RE AT THE SAME

1:04:10 UH, SCALES RIGHT NOW FOR UM NOT

1:04:12 SCALES BUT WE'RE AT THE SAME

1:04:14 YOU KNOW, WE SIGN THE CONTRACT

1:04:15 SIMILAR TIME.

1:04:16 SO BOTH OUR CONTRACTS EXPIRED

1:04:17 THIS PAST UH, JULY 1ST.

1:04:20 SO WE'RE.

1:04:20 WE'RE LOOKING TO NEGOTIATE

1:04:21 RIGHT NOW WITH THE.

1:04:22 CITY AND THEN JUST I MEAN,

1:04:24 MAYBE YOU ALREADY TALKED ABOUT

1:04:25 THIS, BUT A SHORTAGE

1:04:27 OF DETECTIVES SPECIFICALLY LIKE

1:04:28 WHAT IS THAT WHAT DOES THAT

1:04:30 MEAN?

1:04:30 UH, FOR THE CITY, YOU KNOW.

1:04:33 IT MEANS SOME OF THESE

1:04:34 SPECIALIZED UNITS AREN'T

1:04:35 GETTING FILLED AND A LOT OF A

1:04:37 LOT OF THE DISTRICT UNITS

1:04:38 AREN'T GETTING FILLED.

1:04:38 MEANING MEANING THAT'S MORE

1:04:40 CASELOAD FOR ALL OUR MEMBERS,

1:04:41 RIGHT?

1:04:42 SO THAT YOU KNOW, YOU GOT TO GO

1:04:43 PULL MORE VIDEO.

1:04:44 YOU HAVE TO YOU'RE DOING MORE

1:04:45 SEARCH WARRANTS IF YOU'RE DOING

1:04:47 IT THE CASELOADS ARE UH IN SOME

1:04:48 STATES SOME DISTRICTS ARE BUSY

1:04:50 THAN OTHERS.

1:04:51 BUT EVERY DISTRICT NOW IT'S YOU

1:04:52 KNOW, WE TALK TO OUR MEMBERS

1:04:54 THAT THE THEY HAVE ENORMOUS

1:04:56 CASELOADS AND THE WORK IS

1:04:58 GETTING MORE UH WITH TECHNOLOGY

1:05:01 YOU'RE LOOKING FOR MORE STUFF.

1:05:02 THERE'S THERE'S MORE WAYS TO

1:05:03 TRACK PEOPLE.

1:05:03 THERE'S MORE WAYS TO, YOU KNOW,

1:05:04 SOLVE CRIMES AND STUFF LIKE

1:05:05 THAT BUT YOU HAVE TO PUT THE

1:05:06 TIME IN OBVIOUSLY.

1:05:08 SO UH YEAH IT'S.

1:05:09 IT'S IT'S TAXING ON IT MEANS

1:05:12 YOU CAN'T GO HOME AS OFTEN YOU

1:05:13 KNOW YOU'RE WORKING MORE AND

1:05:14 MORE AND MORE ALL THE TIME TO

1:05:15 TO TO SOLVE THESE CASES AND

1:05:17 THEN YOU'RE ALSO GETTING

1:05:18 ORDERED INTO DIFFERENT UM YOU

1:05:20 KNOW, YOU CAN GET ALL INTO IF

1:05:22 YOU'RE IN A DISTRICT YOU GET A

1:05:23 LITTLE OR YOU KNOW SELLING

1:05:23 THERE'S A SHOW FOR THE LAST

1:05:25 HALF OR YOU KNOW, OVERNIGHT

1:05:26 SHIFT OR FIRST HALF OR TO

1:05:27 MIDNIGHT THEN YOU'RE GETTING

1:05:28 ORDERED INTO THAT INTO UNIFORM

1:05:29 IF YOU HAVE TO BUT YOU HAVE TO

1:05:31 PUT YOUR UH CASELOAD ASIDE FOR

1:05:32 THAT FOR THOSE.

1:05:32 EIGHT HOURS.

1:05:33 YEAH.

1:05:34 OKAY.

1:05:35 UH WELL I APPRECIATED IT.

1:05:37 THANKS FOR BEING ABLE TO BEING

1:05:39 AVAILABLE ADVOCATING FOR YOUR

1:05:41 MEMBERS AND, UH.

1:05:42 THANKS FOR EVERYTHING.

1:05:43 YOU DO FOR THE CITY.

1:05:44 UH, UM LET'S SEE.

1:05:46 SO I THINK, UH, KARISHMA, IS

1:05:48 THERE ANYONE ELSE, UH, FOR

1:05:49 PUBLIC TESTIMONY.

1:05:51 NOW, MR CHAIR?

1:05:53 OKAY.

1:05:54 UM, SO LET'S YOU KNOW, WE'RE

1:05:56 GOING TO UH, TRY TO GET ANSWERS

1:05:59 TO MY FELLOW COUNCILORS

1:06:01 QUESTIONS, UH, AND YOU KNOW, I

1:06:04 THAT I HOPEFULLY GET SOME

1:06:05 OF THOSE ANSWERS AND BRING THIS

1:06:06 UP FOR A VOTE ON WEDNESDAY IF

1:06:08 IT TURNS OUT THAT WE NEED SOME

1:06:09 MORE TIME TO GET THE ANSWERS.

1:06:10 UM, I PLAN.

1:06:12 TO WAIT.

1:06:12 MR CHAIR.

1:06:13 CAN I JUMP BACK FOR A QUICK

1:06:14 SECOND?

1:06:14 SURE, COUNCILOR FLYNN.

1:06:16 THANK YOU.

1:06:17 DURING THE BUDGET PROCESS,

1:06:19 UM, THE CITY COUNCIL HAD THE.

1:06:21 OPPORTUNITY TO.

1:06:23 OFFER AMENDMENTS.

1:06:25 WE GOT THAT POWER GRANTED TO

1:06:27 US.

1:06:27 UM, SEVERAL YEARS AGO I OFFERED

1:06:31 AN AMENDMENT.

1:06:33 TO FUND HEALTH AND WELLNESS

1:06:35 PROGRAMS FOR THE BOSTON POLICE

1:06:37 DEPARTMENT.

1:06:37 I BELIEVE I PUT IN 500 A

1:06:39 REQUEST FOR $500,000 THAT WAS

1:06:42 THAT WAS VOTED DOWN BY CITY

1:06:45 COUNCIL COLLEAGUES.

1:06:46 I WANTED TO I WANT TO GET THAT

1:06:48 ON THE RECORD.

1:06:49 UM I WAS ABLE TO GET SOME

1:06:51 FUNDING AND FOR EMS WE THEY

1:06:53 SUPPORTED THAT UM THEY VOTED IT

1:06:55 DOWN FOR BOSTON FIRE ALSO.

1:06:58 BUT I WILL CALL BECAUSE I JUST

1:07:00 WANTED TO GET IT ON THE RECORD.

1:07:01 OUR COLLEAGUES VOTED DOWN THE

1:07:04 THE AMENDMENTS TO ADD MORE

1:07:06 MONEY INTO HEALTH AND WELLNESS

1:07:08 FOR BOSTON POLICE DEPARTMENT.

1:07:10 THE THE THE RESPONSIBILITY AND

1:07:12 BLAME ALSO LIES ON THE CITY

1:07:15 COUNCIL A FAILING TO HAVE THE

1:07:17 COURAGE TO STAND UP FOR WHAT IS

1:07:19 RIGHT.

1:07:20 UM SO WE CAN WE CAN SAY WE'RE

1:07:22 GOING TO ADVOCATE FOR IT AND

1:07:24 NEXT YEAR WHICH WE WILL BUT WE

1:07:26 HAVE THAT WE HAVE THE ABILITY

1:07:27 TO DO IT LAST YEAR AND WE

1:07:29 DECIDED TO NOT DO IT AND WE WE

1:07:31 DID NOT PROVIDE THE THE

1:07:33 CRITICAL LEADERSHIP THAT WAS

1:07:35 NEEDED AT THAT TIME.

1:07:36 SO WE WE HEARD A LOT OF BOSTON

1:07:39 POLICE OFFICERS AND THEIR

1:07:41 FAMILIES.

1:07:41 IT'S TIME FOR THE CITY

1:07:43 COUNCIL TO SHOW A LITTLE BIT

1:07:44 OF A BACKBONE AND STAND UP FOR

1:07:46 WHAT IS RIGHT.

1:07:47 THANK YOU, MR CHAIR.

1:07:48 OKAY.

1:07:49 THANK YOU.

1:07:49 I JUST AS THE CHAIR OF THE

1:07:50 WAYS.

1:07:50 AND MEANS COMMITTEE, YOU.

1:07:51 KNOW, WE.

1:07:52 WORK UH, TOGETHER ON

1:07:53 AMENDMENTS AND.

1:07:54 THIS IS ABOUT YOU.

1:07:55 GOT TO BUILD CONSENSUS WITH

1:07:56 YOUR COLLEAGUES AND FIND THAT

1:07:58 OF COURSE THE AMENDMENTS IT'S

1:08:00 A22 SIDED COIN.

1:08:00 YOU GOT TO FIND MONEY TO TAKE

1:08:02 THE PLACE AGAIN.

1:08:03 MR.

1:08:03 THE IN THE REGULAR UH.

1:08:05 WE DON'T WE DON'T HAVE TO

1:08:06 GET A THAT'S A REAL MISTER

1:08:07 CHAIR.

1:08:08 MISTER CHAIR, I THANK YOU VERY

1:08:09 I RECOMMENDED YOUR COMMENDED

1:08:11 THAT THE MONEY I RECOMMENDED

1:08:12 THE MONEY BE TAKEN OUT

1:08:14 OF OFFICE.

1:08:15 AND NEIGHBORHOOD SERVICES.

1:08:16 I COULD AT LEAST PICK UP TO

1:08:17 THAT.

1:08:17 YES OKAY.

1:08:18 YEAH THAT YOU'RE WE YEAH THAT'S

1:08:21 THAT'S THAT'S HOW THAT THAT

1:08:22 WORKS NOW YOU'VE MADE.

1:08:24 YOUR COMMENTS.

1:08:25 THANK YOU VERY MUCH.

1:08:25 NO NO YOU'RE PASSING THE BUCK,

1:08:27 MR CHAIR.

1:08:27 OKAY.

1:08:28 WELL, UH, I.

1:08:30 I WOULD.

1:08:31 SAY IF YOU WANT.

1:08:32 THAT AMENDMENT PASSED.

1:08:33 PLEASE WORK WITH YOUR

1:08:34 COLLEAGUES AND, UH.

1:08:35 BUILD CONSENSUS.

1:08:36 AND.

1:08:37 YOU CAN GET THAT AMENDMENT.

1:08:38 OKAY.

1:08:39 SO THANK.

1:08:39 YOU VERY MUCH.

1:08:40 THANK YOU TO MY COLLEAGUES FOR

1:08:41 BEING HERE.

1:08:42 THANK YOU TO THE BUDGET

1:08:43 DIRECTOR AND DETECTIVE.

1:08:44 GRIFFIN FOR.

1:08:45 MAKING THE TIME AND.

1:08:46 PROVIDING US WITH YOUR, UH,

1:08:48 THOUGHTFUL ANSWERS.

1:08:49 UH, WITH THAT SAID, UH, THIS

1:08:52 HEARING ON DOCKET NUMBERS 1671

1:08:55 TO.

1:08:55 1674.

1:08:56 IS NOW ADJOURNED.

1:08:58 NO GAVEL.

1:08:58 OKAY.

1:08:59 THANK YOU VERY MUCH.

1:09:00 THANK YOU.

1:09:01 YES.

AI-touched surfaces are labeled; verify against the official record. The tape is embedded from YouTube, never rehosted.