{"candidates":[{"end":325.0,"kind":"decision","reasons":["passes"],"score":0.917,"start":314.6,"t":318.8,"text":"AND AND THE WORK I'M GOING TO TALK ABOUT REALLY CONTINUED THROUGH UM, 2022 AND ADOPTED."},{"end":583.7,"kind":"decision","reasons":["passes"],"score":0.75,"start":577.7,"t":579.2,"text":"UNANIMOUS DECISION BY THE."},{"end":619.7,"kind":"decision","reasons":["passes"],"score":0.75,"start":607.6,"t":609.1,"text":"BY THE UNANIMOUS PASSING OF THE ZONING AMENDMENT."},{"end":655.6,"kind":"decision","reasons":["discussed"],"score":0.738,"start":644.1,"t":645.6,"text":"TO TO ADOPTING THE A F H BY EXECUTIVE ORDER SHOULD SHE."},{"end":753.7,"kind":"decision","reasons":["discussed"],"score":0.747,"start":738.1,"t":739.6,"text":"THE ADOPTION OF THE BOSTON ASSESSMENT OF FAIR HOUSING IN 2022, AS LINCOLN MENTIONED, IS AN IMPORTANT VICTORY FOR THE CITY IN MASSACHUSETTS."},{"end":780.0,"kind":"decision","reasons":["discussed"],"score":0.6,"start":772.0,"t":775.5,"text":"DECISIONS SINCE."},{"end":810.2,"kind":"decision","reasons":["discussed"],"score":0.747,"start":795.7,"t":797.2,"text":"AS WE KNOW, THE ADOPTION OF AFFIRMATIVELY FURTHERING FAIR HOUSING INTO BOSTON'S ZONING CODE WAS YET ANOTHER MAJOR VICTORY AND MOVED THE CITY CLOSER TO A."},{"end":833.1,"kind":"decision","reasons":["passes"],"score":0.887,"start":820.7,"t":823.7,"text":"SUBSEQUENTLY, THIS STRATEGY WAS ADOPTED BY THE CITY COUNCIL AND ENDORSED BY MAIL WASH."},{"end":881.2,"kind":"decision","reasons":["passes"],"score":0.893,"start":860.1,"t":873.3,"text":"THIS EO ESTABLISH A MODERATING COMMITTEE CHARGED WITH MEETING QUARTERLY WITH CITY AGENCIES TO REVIEW PROGRESS OR LACK OF PROGRESS IN THE IMPLEMENTATION OF THE 14 GOALS OUTLINED IN THE ADOPTED FH."},{"end":911.1,"kind":"decision","reasons":["passes"],"score":1.0,"start":894.2,"t":898.3,"text":"IN JUNE 2025 THE BOSTON CITY COUNCIL UNANIMOUSLY ADOPTED ONE MEMBER ABSENT A RESOLUTION ENDORSING AFFIRMATIVELY FURTHERING FAIR HOUSING."},{"end":991.4,"kind":"tension","reasons":["pushback: crisis"],"score":0.608,"start":968.4,"t":983.5,"text":"HIGH INTEREST RATES, CONSTRUCTION COST, THE SUPPLY OF HOUSING, HIGH HOUSING COST AND THE INSECURE ECONOMIC SITUATION FACING THOUSANDS OF BOSTON FAMILIES EXACERBATE BOSTON'S DEEP HOUSING AFFORDABILITY CRISIS."},{"end":1054.7,"kind":"tension","reasons":["pushback: crisis"],"score":0.538,"start":1034.9,"t":1040.9,"text":"AS WE PURSUE ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT AND STRATEGIES TO RESPOND TO THE CITY'S HOUSING CRISIS, WE CANNOT FORGET THAT THESE ARE THE PEOPLE AND FAMILIES WHO WOULD BE LEFT OUT OF DECENT AND AFFORDABLE HOUSING."},{"end":1319.2,"kind":"tension","reasons":["pushback: complaint"],"score":0.542,"start":1290.3,"t":1300.2,"text":"THE CITY OF BOSTON'S FAIR HOUSING COMMISSION WAS EXPLICITLY REQUIRED TO ENFORCE FAIR HOUSING LAWS, MAINTAIN A ROBUST COMPLAINT INVESTIGATION SYSTEM AND CONDUCT A MINORITY NEEDS ASSESSMENT AND IDENTIFY BARRIERS TO HOUSING"},{"end":1435.4,"kind":"tension","reasons":["pushback: concern, concerned"],"score":0.626,"start":1417.4,"t":1418.9,"text":"WE'RE CONCERNED THAT THE OFFICE OF FAIR HOUSING IS NOT GETTING THE RESOURCES AND SUPPORT THAT IT NEEDS TO LEAD THE CITY'S FAIR HOUSING EFFORTS."},{"end":1862.5,"kind":"tension","reasons":["pushback: concern"],"score":0.588,"start":1849.1,"t":1851.6,"text":"UM AND SO RESIDENTS SHOULD BE ABLE TO SEE WHAT CONCERNS ARE RAISED BY THE BOSTON INTER AGENCY FAIR HOUSING DEVELOPMENT COMMITTEE AND WHAT'S CHANGED AND WHETHER THOSE COMMITMENTS WERE KEPT."},{"end":2107.5,"kind":"tension","reasons":["pushback: opposed, oppose"],"score":0.626,"start":2090.2,"t":2096.9,"text":"I THINK THEY BEEN MENTIONED AS LIKE HAVING LIKE UH A POSITION THAT HELPS COORDINATE ALL THE EFFORTS ACROSS THE CITY OPPOSED TO EVERYONE DOING IT WITHIN THEIR OWN SILOED DEPARTMENT."},{"end":3147.1,"kind":"tension","reasons":["pushback: concern, concerned"],"score":0.626,"start":3134.9,"t":3139.7,"text":"WE SHOULD, YOU KNOW, HAVE REGULAR CHECK INS WITH OUR YOU KNOW, COUNCILORS WHO ARE CONCERNED ABOUT THIS TO SHARE HOW WE FEEL AND MAKE SURE YOU ALL ARE BACKING US UP ON THAT."},{"end":10287.9,"kind":"tension","reasons":["pushback: concern, concerned"],"score":0.626,"start":10258.8,"t":10278.6,"text":"MY MY QUESTION I WOULD LIKE YOU TO ANSWER UM IF YOU PLEASE IS ON YOUR GOAL NUMBER ONE INCREASE HOUSING ASSET ACCESS FOR PERSONS WITH DISABILITIES OLDER ADULTS OF I REPRESENT THE MOST RESIDENTS LIVING IN PUBLIC HOUSING OF"}],"clips":[{"end":325.0,"keep":true,"kind":"decision","label":"AND AND THE WORK I'M GOING TO TALK ABOUT REALLY CONTINUED…","offset":0.0,"ratios":["16x9","9x16"],"reasons":["passes"],"score":0.917,"start":314.6,"t":318.8,"text":"AND AND THE WORK I'M GOING TO TALK ABOUT REALLY CONTINUED THROUGH UM, 2022 AND ADOPTED."},{"end":583.7,"keep":true,"kind":"decision","label":"UNANIMOUS DECISION BY THE.","offset":0.0,"ratios":["16x9","9x16"],"reasons":["passes"],"score":0.75,"start":577.7,"t":579.2,"text":"UNANIMOUS DECISION BY THE."},{"end":619.7,"keep":true,"kind":"decision","label":"BY THE UNANIMOUS PASSING OF THE ZONING AMENDMENT.","offset":0.0,"ratios":["16x9","9x16"],"reasons":["passes"],"score":0.75,"start":607.6,"t":609.1,"text":"BY THE UNANIMOUS PASSING OF THE ZONING AMENDMENT."},{"end":655.6,"keep":false,"kind":"decision","label":"TO TO ADOPTING THE A F H BY EXECUTIVE ORDER SHOULD SHE.","offset":0.0,"ratios":["16x9","9x16"],"reasons":["discussed"],"score":0.738,"start":644.1,"t":645.6,"text":"TO TO ADOPTING THE A F H BY EXECUTIVE ORDER SHOULD SHE."},{"end":753.7,"keep":false,"kind":"decision","label":"THE ADOPTION OF THE BOSTON ASSESSMENT OF FAIR HOUSING IN 2022,…","offset":0.0,"ratios":["16x9","9x16"],"reasons":["discussed"],"score":0.747,"start":738.1,"t":739.6,"text":"THE ADOPTION OF THE BOSTON ASSESSMENT OF FAIR HOUSING IN 2022, AS LINCOLN MENTIONED, IS AN IMPORTANT VICTORY FOR THE CITY IN MASSACHUSETTS."},{"end":780.0,"keep":false,"kind":"decision","label":"DECISIONS SINCE.","offset":0.0,"ratios":["16x9","9x16"],"reasons":["discussed"],"score":0.6,"start":772.0,"t":775.5,"text":"DECISIONS SINCE."},{"end":810.2,"keep":false,"kind":"decision","label":"AS WE KNOW, THE ADOPTION OF AFFIRMATIVELY FURTHERING FAIR…","offset":0.0,"ratios":["16x9","9x16"],"reasons":["discussed"],"score":0.747,"start":795.7,"t":797.2,"text":"AS WE KNOW, THE ADOPTION OF AFFIRMATIVELY FURTHERING FAIR HOUSING INTO BOSTON'S ZONING CODE WAS YET ANOTHER MAJOR VICTORY AND MOVED THE CITY CLOSER TO A."},{"end":833.1,"keep":false,"kind":"decision","label":"SUBSEQUENTLY, THIS STRATEGY WAS ADOPTED BY THE CITY COUNCIL AND…","offset":0.0,"ratios":["16x9","9x16"],"reasons":["passes"],"score":0.887,"start":820.7,"t":823.7,"text":"SUBSEQUENTLY, THIS STRATEGY WAS ADOPTED BY THE CITY COUNCIL AND ENDORSED BY MAIL WASH."},{"end":881.2,"keep":false,"kind":"decision","label":"THIS EO ESTABLISH A MODERATING COMMITTEE CHARGED WITH MEETING…","offset":0.0,"ratios":["16x9","9x16"],"reasons":["passes"],"score":0.893,"start":860.1,"t":873.3,"text":"THIS EO ESTABLISH A MODERATING COMMITTEE CHARGED WITH MEETING QUARTERLY WITH CITY AGENCIES TO REVIEW PROGRESS OR LACK OF PROGRESS IN THE IMPLEMENTATION OF THE 14 GOALS OUTLINED IN THE ADOPTED FH."},{"end":911.1,"keep":false,"kind":"decision","label":"IN JUNE 2025 THE BOSTON CITY COUNCIL UNANIMOUSLY ADOPTED ONE…","offset":0.0,"ratios":["16x9","9x16"],"reasons":["passes"],"score":1.0,"start":894.2,"t":898.3,"text":"IN JUNE 2025 THE BOSTON CITY COUNCIL UNANIMOUSLY ADOPTED ONE MEMBER ABSENT A RESOLUTION ENDORSING AFFIRMATIVELY FURTHERING FAIR HOUSING."},{"end":991.4,"keep":false,"kind":"tension","label":"HIGH INTEREST RATES, CONSTRUCTION COST, THE SUPPLY OF HOUSING,…","offset":0.0,"ratios":["16x9","9x16"],"reasons":["pushback: crisis"],"score":0.608,"start":968.4,"t":983.5,"text":"HIGH INTEREST RATES, CONSTRUCTION COST, THE SUPPLY OF HOUSING, HIGH HOUSING COST AND THE INSECURE ECONOMIC SITUATION FACING THOUSANDS OF BOSTON FAMILIES EXACERBATE BOSTON'S DEEP HOUSING AFFORDABILITY CRISIS."},{"end":1054.7,"keep":false,"kind":"tension","label":"AS WE PURSUE ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT AND STRATEGIES TO RESPOND TO…","offset":0.0,"ratios":["16x9","9x16"],"reasons":["pushback: crisis"],"score":0.538,"start":1034.9,"t":1040.9,"text":"AS WE PURSUE ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT AND STRATEGIES TO RESPOND TO THE CITY'S HOUSING CRISIS, WE CANNOT FORGET THAT THESE ARE THE PEOPLE AND FAMILIES WHO WOULD BE LEFT OUT OF DECENT AND AFFORDABLE HOUSING."},{"end":1319.2,"keep":false,"kind":"tension","label":"THE CITY OF BOSTON'S FAIR HOUSING COMMISSION WAS EXPLICITLY…","offset":0.0,"ratios":["16x9","9x16"],"reasons":["pushback: complaint"],"score":0.542,"start":1290.3,"t":1300.2,"text":"THE CITY OF BOSTON'S FAIR HOUSING COMMISSION WAS EXPLICITLY REQUIRED TO ENFORCE FAIR HOUSING LAWS, MAINTAIN A ROBUST COMPLAINT INVESTIGATION SYSTEM AND CONDUCT A MINORITY NEEDS ASSESSMENT AND IDENTIFY BARRIERS TO HOUSING"},{"end":1435.4,"keep":false,"kind":"tension","label":"WE'RE CONCERNED THAT THE OFFICE OF FAIR HOUSING IS NOT GETTING…","offset":0.0,"ratios":["16x9","9x16"],"reasons":["pushback: concern, concerned"],"score":0.626,"start":1417.4,"t":1418.9,"text":"WE'RE CONCERNED THAT THE OFFICE OF FAIR HOUSING IS NOT GETTING THE RESOURCES AND SUPPORT THAT IT NEEDS TO LEAD THE CITY'S FAIR HOUSING EFFORTS."},{"end":1862.5,"keep":false,"kind":"tension","label":"UM AND SO RESIDENTS SHOULD BE ABLE TO SEE WHAT CONCERNS ARE…","offset":0.0,"ratios":["16x9","9x16"],"reasons":["pushback: concern"],"score":0.588,"start":1849.1,"t":1851.6,"text":"UM AND SO RESIDENTS SHOULD BE ABLE TO SEE WHAT CONCERNS ARE RAISED BY THE BOSTON INTER AGENCY FAIR HOUSING DEVELOPMENT COMMITTEE AND WHAT'S CHANGED AND WHETHER THOSE COMMITMENTS WERE KEPT."},{"end":2107.5,"keep":false,"kind":"tension","label":"I THINK THEY BEEN MENTIONED AS LIKE HAVING LIKE UH A POSITION…","offset":0.0,"ratios":["16x9","9x16"],"reasons":["pushback: opposed, oppose"],"score":0.626,"start":2090.2,"t":2096.9,"text":"I THINK THEY BEEN MENTIONED AS LIKE HAVING LIKE UH A POSITION THAT HELPS COORDINATE ALL THE EFFORTS ACROSS THE CITY OPPOSED TO EVERYONE DOING IT WITHIN THEIR OWN SILOED DEPARTMENT."},{"end":3147.1,"keep":false,"kind":"tension","label":"WE SHOULD, YOU KNOW, HAVE REGULAR CHECK INS WITH OUR YOU KNOW,…","offset":0.0,"ratios":["16x9","9x16"],"reasons":["pushback: concern, concerned"],"score":0.626,"start":3134.9,"t":3139.7,"text":"WE SHOULD, YOU KNOW, HAVE REGULAR CHECK INS WITH OUR YOU KNOW, COUNCILORS WHO ARE CONCERNED ABOUT THIS TO SHARE HOW WE FEEL AND MAKE SURE YOU ALL ARE BACKING US UP ON THAT."},{"end":10287.9,"keep":false,"kind":"tension","label":"MY MY QUESTION I WOULD LIKE YOU TO ANSWER UM IF YOU PLEASE IS…","offset":0.0,"ratios":["16x9","9x16"],"reasons":["pushback: concern, concerned"],"score":0.626,"start":10258.8,"t":10278.6,"text":"MY MY QUESTION I WOULD LIKE YOU TO ANSWER UM IF YOU PLEASE IS ON YOUR GOAL NUMBER ONE INCREASE HOUSING ASSET ACCESS FOR PERSONS WITH DISABILITIES OLDER ADULTS OF I REPRESENT THE MOST RESIDENTS LIVING IN PUBLIC HOUSING OF"}],"copy":{"alt_text":["Video clip from Housing and Community Development on September 29, 2026: AND AND THE WORK I'M GOING TO TALK ABOUT REALLY CONTINUED…","Video clip from Housing and Community Development on September 29, 2026: UNANIMOUS DECISION BY THE.","Video clip from Housing and Community Development on September 29, 2026: BY THE UNANIMOUS PASSING OF THE ZONING AMENDMENT.","Video clip from Housing and Community Development on September 29, 2026: TO TO ADOPTING THE A F H BY EXECUTIVE ORDER SHOULD SHE.","Video clip from Housing and Community Development on September 29, 2026: THE ADOPTION OF THE BOSTON ASSESSMENT OF FAIR HOUSING IN 2022,…","Video clip from Housing and Community Development on September 29, 2026: DECISIONS SINCE.","Video clip from Housing and Community Development on September 29, 2026: AS WE KNOW, THE ADOPTION OF AFFIRMATIVELY FURTHERING FAIR…","Video clip from Housing and Community Development on September 29, 2026: SUBSEQUENTLY, THIS STRATEGY WAS ADOPTED BY THE CITY COUNCIL AND…","Video clip from Housing and Community Development on September 29, 2026: THIS EO ESTABLISH A MODERATING COMMITTEE CHARGED WITH MEETING…","Video clip from Housing and Community Development on September 29, 2026: IN JUNE 2025 THE BOSTON CITY COUNCIL UNANIMOUSLY ADOPTED ONE…","Video clip from Housing and Community Development on September 29, 2026: HIGH INTEREST RATES, CONSTRUCTION COST, THE SUPPLY OF HOUSING,…","Video clip from Housing and Community Development on September 29, 2026: AS WE PURSUE ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT AND STRATEGIES TO RESPOND TO…","Video clip from Housing and Community Development on September 29, 2026: THE CITY OF BOSTON'S FAIR HOUSING COMMISSION WAS EXPLICITLY…","Video clip from Housing and Community Development on September 29, 2026: WE'RE CONCERNED THAT THE OFFICE OF FAIR HOUSING IS NOT GETTING…","Video clip from Housing and Community Development on September 29, 2026: UM AND SO RESIDENTS SHOULD BE ABLE TO SEE WHAT CONCERNS ARE…","Video clip from Housing and Community Development on September 29, 2026: I THINK THEY BEEN MENTIONED AS LIKE HAVING LIKE UH A POSITION…","Video clip from Housing and Community Development on September 29, 2026: WE SHOULD, YOU KNOW, HAVE REGULAR CHECK INS WITH OUR YOU KNOW,…","Video clip from Housing and Community Development on September 29, 2026: MY MY QUESTION I WOULD LIKE YOU TO ANSWER UM IF YOU PLEASE IS…"],"chapters":[{"label":"AND AND THE WORK I'M GOING TO TALK ABOUT REALLY CONTINUED…","t":314.6},{"label":"UNANIMOUS DECISION BY THE.","t":577.7},{"label":"BY THE UNANIMOUS PASSING OF THE ZONING AMENDMENT.","t":607.6},{"label":"TO TO ADOPTING THE A F H BY EXECUTIVE ORDER SHOULD SHE.","t":644.1},{"label":"THE ADOPTION OF THE BOSTON ASSESSMENT OF FAIR HOUSING IN 2022,…","t":738.1},{"label":"DECISIONS SINCE.","t":772.0},{"label":"AS WE KNOW, THE ADOPTION OF AFFIRMATIVELY FURTHERING FAIR…","t":795.7},{"label":"SUBSEQUENTLY, THIS STRATEGY WAS ADOPTED BY THE CITY COUNCIL AND…","t":820.7},{"label":"THIS EO ESTABLISH A MODERATING COMMITTEE CHARGED WITH MEETING…","t":860.1},{"label":"IN JUNE 2025 THE BOSTON CITY COUNCIL UNANIMOUSLY ADOPTED ONE…","t":894.2},{"label":"HIGH INTEREST RATES, CONSTRUCTION COST, THE SUPPLY OF HOUSING,…","t":968.4},{"label":"AS WE PURSUE ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT AND STRATEGIES TO RESPOND TO…","t":1034.9},{"label":"THE CITY OF BOSTON'S FAIR HOUSING COMMISSION WAS EXPLICITLY…","t":1290.3},{"label":"WE'RE CONCERNED THAT THE OFFICE OF FAIR HOUSING IS NOT GETTING…","t":1417.4},{"label":"UM AND SO RESIDENTS SHOULD BE ABLE TO SEE WHAT CONCERNS ARE…","t":1849.1},{"label":"I THINK THEY BEEN MENTIONED AS LIKE HAVING LIKE UH A POSITION…","t":2090.2},{"label":"WE SHOULD, YOU KNOW, HAVE REGULAR CHECK INS WITH OUR YOU KNOW,…","t":3134.9},{"label":"MY MY QUESTION I WOULD LIKE YOU TO ANSWER UM IF YOU PLEASE IS…","t":10258.8}],"description":"Housing and Community Development on September 29, 2026\n\nEFFORTS ACROSS THE CITY OPPOSED I'M WONDERING IF YOU FEEL HEY HUNDRED MILLION DOLLAR FUND UH HOUSING I'VE FILED A COMPLAINT HOUSING CRISIS DEMANDS URGENCY\n\nMoments:\n5:14 — AND AND THE WORK I'M GOING TO TALK ABOUT REALLY CONTINUED…\n9:37 — UNANIMOUS DECISION BY THE.\n10:07 — BY THE UNANIMOUS PASSING OF THE ZONING AMENDMENT.\n10:44 — TO TO ADOPTING THE A F H BY EXECUTIVE ORDER SHOULD SHE.\n12:18 — THE ADOPTION OF THE BOSTON ASSESSMENT OF FAIR HOUSING IN 2022,…\n12:52 — DECISIONS SINCE.\n13:15 — AS WE KNOW, THE ADOPTION OF AFFIRMATIVELY FURTHERING FAIR…\n13:40 — SUBSEQUENTLY, THIS STRATEGY WAS ADOPTED BY THE CITY COUNCIL AND…\n14:20 — THIS EO ESTABLISH A MODERATING COMMITTEE CHARGED WITH MEETING…\n14:54 — IN JUNE 2025 THE BOSTON CITY COUNCIL UNANIMOUSLY ADOPTED ONE…\n16:08 — HIGH INTEREST RATES, CONSTRUCTION COST, THE SUPPLY OF HOUSING,…\n17:14 — AS WE PURSUE ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT AND STRATEGIES TO RESPOND TO…\n21:30 — THE CITY OF BOSTON'S FAIR HOUSING COMMISSION WAS EXPLICITLY…\n23:37 — WE'RE CONCERNED THAT THE OFFICE OF FAIR HOUSING IS NOT GETTING…\n30:49 — UM AND SO RESIDENTS SHOULD BE ABLE TO SEE WHAT CONCERNS ARE…\n34:50 — I THINK THEY BEEN MENTIONED AS LIKE HAVING LIKE UH A POSITION…\n52:14 — WE SHOULD, YOU KNOW, HAVE REGULAR CHECK INS WITH OUR YOU KNOW,…\n2:50:58 — MY MY QUESTION I WOULD LIKE YOU TO ANSWER UM IF YOU PLEASE IS…\n\nFull program and record at the station. Assembled from the transcript.","newsletter":"EFFORTS ACROSS THE CITY OPPOSED I'M WONDERING IF YOU FEEL HEY HUNDRED MILLION DOLLAR FUND UH HOUSING I'VE FILED A COMPLAINT HOUSING CRISIS DEMANDS URGENCY","origin":"extractive — assembled from the transcript, no model","social":{"feed":"EFFORTS ACROSS THE CITY OPPOSED I'M WONDERING IF YOU FEEL HEY HUNDRED MILLION DOLLAR FUND UH HOUSING I'VE FILED A COMPLAINT HOUSING CRISIS DEMANDS URGENCY (full program at the station)","vertical":"AND AND THE WORK I'M GOING TO TALK ABOUT REALLY CONTINUED… — Housing and Community Development on September 29, 2026"},"titles":["AND AND THE WORK I'M GOING TO TALK ABOUT REALLY CONTINUED THROUGH UM,","Housing and Community Development on September 29, 2026"]},"files":[],"meta":{"body":"City Council Committee","date":"2026-09-29","duration":13191.278,"pid":"MClPp2uo9EQ","source":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MClPp2uo9EQ","still":"/app/stills/MClPp2uo9EQ.jpg","thumb":"https://i.ytimg.com/vi/MClPp2uo9EQ/hqdefault.jpg","title":"Housing and Community Development on September 29, 2026","town":"Boston","url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MClPp2uo9EQ","video_id":"MClPp2uo9EQ"},"slug":"MClPp2uo9EQ","version":1}